Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Reviewing the impact of the then recently available archival sources on research into the German Communist Party (KPD), Sigrid Koch-Baumgarten observed that the quintessential question for researchers – the balance between exogenous and endogenous factors in shaping communism – was here to stay. 1 Th is is a question which has been framed in a number of ways, but in one form or another it is embedded across the varying national historiographies of a transnational movement. 2 Th e contributions to this issue of Twentieth Century Communism – which draws on a selection of papers presented to a conference at the University of Glamorgan (2011) – explore the relationship between the universalising intentions of Bolshevism and the prism of local conditions, which fragmented the light from the East to produce a spectrum of communisms.3 Each author places the balance – as Koch-Baumgarten termed it – at a diff erent point on the scales in weighing up these exogenous and endogenous infl uences; but they all, to one extent or another, point towards many shades of ‘red’, as a diversity of specifi c ‘local’ factors reacted with the Soviet-issue pigment. Before pointing the way ahead to the individual contributions, this introductory discussion fi rst itself engages with this most enduring debate in communist studies, primarily using the German Communist Party as an example. Th e main point is as basic as it is fundamental: the ‘monolith’ was undeniably a Bolshevik aim, and was central to western constructions of communism; but the infl uence of very diverse ‘local’ conditions meant that it remained an unfulfi lled statement of intent.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Norman LaPorte (2013) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: