Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
I believe there are four major defects in the Administration's proposals for changing the federal personnel system that need to be corrected to avoid undermining the impartiality and effectiveness of the civil service. At the same time, it should be recognized that many changes in law which the President seeks will make it possible for the agencies to operate better, and these should be enacted soon. However, the serious weaknesses in the proposals need to be eliminated. Otherwise, there will be political and personalfavoritism in the civil service on a grand scale and the citizens will be the losers. One major weakness relates to the Administration's proposal for a Senior Executive Service with its grant of sweeping authority for presidential appointees to reassign and demote almost all top career executives and replace them with political or other career appointees more to their individual liking. Career executives represent an important national resource which the federal government develops at considerable cost; their central commitment is to non-partisan professional advice and the impartial administration of the laws, and both would be jeopardized by such a grant of authority. Presidential appointees in successive administrations generally have decided who would fill the career executive vacancies in their agencies based on clear evidence of a high order of competence and responsiveness; and if, in a few instances, a career executive's subsequent performance would be less than acceptable, then only an incompetent or unconcerned presidential appointee would find it impracticable to make necessary changes. Of course, making such changes involves something more than a wave of the hand, as, indeed, it should, because what we are dealing with here is not only the need for fair treatment of career executives, but, equally, if not more important, the larger public interest. Who are these presidential appointees who would exercise this new power? Most are exceptionally able and highly dedicated to the national interest. In our democratic process they constitute the vital link between the decisions
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Bernard Rosen (1978) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: