Key result
M-mode Q-to-motion onset isolates activation effects better than strain intervals in repaired tetralogy of Fallot.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
We thank Dr Abdul-Khaliq and his colleagues for their interest in our study 1 and for their comments to Circulation. We submit that apparent differences between our 2 studies 1,2 are largely methodological in origin. In order to isolate the potential effects of activation, we measured the time interval from Q to onset of motion using M-mode with its high repetition rate. Abdul-Khaliq et al used strain imaging to measure the time interval to maximum strain, which they took to coincide with aortic valve closure (A2). 2 This latter interval also includes ventricular ejection and is thus potentially influenced by loading conditions. As we pointed out in our article, we had very similar results when we took the time interval to peak shortening velocity, which is inscribed at mid ejection and thus subjected to similar influences. We note that heart rate was not found to be a significant determinant in the particular circumstances of their study. However, the time from Q to A2 has been extensively investigated in the setting of the systolic time intervals, and its rate dependence has been clearly documented. 3 Such dependence must always be recognized among other potential confounding factors when any time interval that includes ventricular ejection is studied.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Uebing et al. (2008) conducted a letter in Repaired Tetralogy of Fallot. M-mode echocardiography (time interval from Q to onset of motion) vs. Strain imaging (time interval to maximum strain at aortic valve closure) was evaluated. M-mode measurement of Q-to-motion onset isolates activation effects in repaired tetralogy of Fallot, whereas strain intervals to aortic valve closure include rate-dependent ejection.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: