Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
To the Editor:Astigmatism is a common optical aberration where incident light hitting a curved refractive surface, with one meridian steeper than the other, results in a blurred, defocused image.In the eye, this commonly occurs in the cornea."With-the-rule" astigmatism is where the vertical meridian is steeper than the horizontal, and "againstthe-rule" astigmatism is where the opposite is true.Sports ball analogies are often used to describe astigmatism to patients.Although sport has the power to unite people across the globe, when it comes to selecting which ball best describes astigmatism, the lines are somewhat blurred.In the United Kingdom, eyes without astigmatism are round "like a football" but in the United States and Australia, eyes with astigmatism are irregularly shaped "like a football."These analogies are found in patient literature published in the English language that, due to the internet, has a global reach.The apparent contradiction can be confusing for patients depending on the country the information originates and the readers' sporting cultural backgrounds.Of course, this is because a football in the United Kingdom (equivalent to a United States "soccer" ball) is spherical, equally round in all meridians, and very different to United States and Australian footballs, which are ovoid in shape, with one axis steeper than the other.By contrast, astigmatic eyes in the United Kingdom are described as rugby ball shaped.The pooled global prevalence of astigmatism is high, estimated at 40% (95% CI: 34% to 47%). 1 Figure 1 shows screenshots from reliable patient information sources in the United Kingdom, 2 United States, 3 and Australia, 4 which all use football analogies to explain astigmatism that are subject to misunderstanding.Many cities are highly multicultural where patients' understanding of a "football" may differ to the sporting cultural norm of the country they reside in.Although internet searches often yield locally relevant results likely to appeal to most readers in an area, English medical literature from different countries is accessible to patients and could be a source of confusion.Whether you are with-the-rule or against-the-rule, the age-old contentious debate about which football is the real football has no end in sight.Due consideration to patients' backgrounds and sporting, cultural norms should be given when explaining astigmatism using football analogies.Health care professionals should avoid arguing about an aberration and not lose focus on delivering clear, unambiguous patient information literature and consider using alternative more universally accepted shapes, such as ping-pong balls or eggs.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Jarrar et al. (2025) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: