Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
In spite of the fact that Rights of Nature (RoN), the perspective that natural objects, such as trees and rivers, should have legal rights like humans, has its beginnings in the United States of America (USA), it is in developing countries that it blossomed. Its emergence was catalysed by the realization that the human-based philosophy of development, anthropocentrism, has complicated the environmental crisis, and therefore one with nature as its centre, ecocentrism, is needed for effective environmental management. This paper analyses the theoretical and philosophical basis of RoN, its evolutionary trajectory and the challenges to its effectiveness in the developing countries. Documents/publications of those countries that have or attempted to adopt RoN, environmental civil society organisations, and those of researchers, are the main sources of data/information. Legal personhood provides the theoretical basis of RoN while its philosophical stance is influenced by the indigenous people’s perspective on nature as a living system that is sacred and requiring harmonious relationship with humans. Ecuador which amended its constitution to include RoN provisions in 2008, is the first country in the developing world and the second globally after Tamaqua Borough, USA, to adopt RoN. Currently all the countries having country-wide RoN are in the developing world. Apart from Ecuador, others are Bolivia, Uganda and Panama. The introduction of RoN in these other countries was through legislation. Mexico and Brazil are countries where municipalities are the spatial units endowed with rights. Rivers, such as in Bangladesh, Colombia, India and Peru, are the most common natural entities endowed with rights. Ecuador and Bolivia are the earliest adopters of RoN while Panama and Peru are the most recent. Several challenges hinder an effective operation of RoN. These include ambiguity of the phraseology of RoN, inappropriate RoN guardianship systems, limited scope and coverage, conflict between the economic structure of the countries and RoN, and the high level of corruption in many of the countries. In order for RoN to succeed, the emergent challenges must be addressed.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Ikporukpo et al. (2025) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: