Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
After careful evaluation of the calculated data, we can conclude that: When using an IQA scheme, great care must be taken when checking results based on Bader atoms. Namely, the magnitude of atomic charges should be analyzed by comparison with other alternative methods. Otherwise, the results may be very controversial from a chemical point of view, e.g., a very large electrostatic contribution to truly covalent bonds. When using an IQA scheme, great care must be taken when checking results based on Bader atoms. Namely, the magnitude of atomic charges should be analyzed by comparison with other alternative methods. Otherwise, the results may be very controversial from a chemical point of view, e.g., a very large electrostatic contribution to truly covalent bonds. In the case of the conventional EDA technique, it is highly desirable to provide additional analysis of how the EDA terms are distributed over one- and two-center components. This is exactly the approach developed and used in this article. It proves to be a very useful tool that helps to analyze and interpret EDA data in more depth. In the case of the conventional EDA technique, it is highly desirable to provide additional analysis of how the EDA terms are distributed over one- and two-center components. This is exactly the approach developed and used in this article. It proves to be a very useful tool that helps to analyze and interpret EDA data in more depth. It is believed that fulfillment of the mentioned conditions will prevent future disagreements such as those discussed concerning the two articles in question. It is believed that fulfillment of the mentioned conditions will prevent future disagreements such as those discussed concerning the two articles in question. As a result of such a comprehensive approach, it can be clearly stated that, in contrast to the pyramidal form p -LiCF 3 (existing predominantly due to Li − C bond), the more stable inverted structure i -LiCF 3 is organized as a result of collective bonding between Li and three fluorine atoms through a moderate covalent 2 e -multicenter interaction with an energy of −62 kcal/mol per one Li − F pair. For consistent comparison of the discussed results, the geometry of p -LiCF 3 was taken from ref. . Such xyz -data for the inverted i -LiCF 3 system was missed there, so it was optimized by the M06-2X functional using def2-TZVPP basis set, as proposed in ref. . It should be noted that close geometries were obtained in ref. using another basis set TZ2P. All IQA and EDA energy decomposition analyzes were performed using the TWOe code ( ver . Z2), which includes now a developed Model DFT approach for correct atomic and interatomic partitioning of the M06-2X xc -terms. Additional data on charges, zfs -based IQA and EDA results, and geometries used are available in Supporting Information free of charge.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Pavel M. Polestshuk (2024) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: