Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The ability to move DNA into an organism and thereby alter its phenotype is central to both basic and applied molecular biology. Transformation is a simple task withEscherichia coli or Saccharomyces cerevisiae, but is usually more difficult with multicellular eukaryotes and can be particularly challenging with some important plant species. However, for Arabidopsis, in planta transformation methods have been developed that are incredibly simple. Attempts to apply in planta transformation methods to other plant species have often failed. This may be due in part to a poor understanding of the mechanisms that underlie the successful Arabidopsis transformation method. Studies of Arabidopsis transformation have accordingly been pursued, and three groups have recently published relevant findings. Successful in planta transformation of the legume Medicago truncatula was also reported recently, showing that the method can be adapted to other species. The cellular target for transformation of M. truncatula may differ somewhat from the target in Arabidopsis. The above findings may guide future efforts to improve transformation of other plant species. This update opens by briefly reviewing transformation protocols that avoid tissue culture, and their impressive utility. Recent findings concerning Arabidopsis and M. truncatula transformation are then described. The review closes by commenting on possible avenues for improvement of transformation in other plant species. Genetic transformation of plants occurs naturally (Hooykaas and Schilperoort, 1992). Scientists have been able to carry out controlled plant transformation with specific genes since the mid-1970s. The most common methods for introduction of DNA into plant cells useAgrobacterium tumefaciens bacteria or rapidly propelled tungsten microprojectiles that have been coated with DNA (Birch, 1997;Hansen and Wright, 1999). Other methods such as electroporation, microinjection, or delivery by virus have also been exploited. To allow physiological selection of cells that have been successfully transformed, the DNA of interest is typically cloned adjacent to DNA for a selectable marker gene such as nptII (encoding kanamycin antibiotic resistance). Genetic transformation can be transient or stable, and transformed cells may or may not give rise to gametes that pass genetic material on to subsequent generations. Transformation of protoplasts, callus culture cells, or other isolated plant cells is usually straightforward and can be used for short-term studies of gene function (Gelvin and Schilperoort, 1998). Transformation of leaf mesophyll cells or other cells within intact plants may in some cases broaden the utility of single-cell assays (e.g. Tang et al., 1996). Exciting new approaches such as virus-induced gene silencing may also be applicable for some studies (Baulcombe, 1999). In the era of genomics these short-term assays will become increasingly important. However, in many cases it is desirable or necessary to produce a uniformly transformed plant that carries the transgene in the nuclear genome as a single Mendelian locus. The generation of genetically homogeneous plants carrying the same transformation event in all cells has typically presented two separate hurdles: transformation of plant cells and regeneration of intact, reproductively competent plants from those transformed cells (Birch, 1997; Hansen and Wright, 1999). Although many successful plant regeneration methods have been developed, these methods often require a great deal of protocol refinement and the focused effort of expert practitioners. It is unfortunate that plant regeneration from single transformed cells often produces mutations ranging from single base changes or small rearrangements to the loss of entire chromosomes. In addition, significant epigenetic changes (for example, in DNA methylation) can also occur (Phillips et al., 1994). It is often necessary to generate and screen a dozen or more independent plant lines transformed with the same construct to find lines that have suffered minimal genetic damage and that carry a simple insertion event (Birch, 1997; Hansen and Wright, 1999). Transformation is feasible in many plant species, but has required acceptance of the above limitations. A number of laboratories have pursued plant transformation methods that avoid tissue culture or regeneration. In many cases these methods have targeted meristems or other tissues that will ultimately give rise to gametes (Chee and Slighton, 1995; Birch, 1997). The same is true of popular tissue culture-based transformation methods for corn, rice, wheat, and soybean, which target young apical meristems for transformation (Birch, 1997). For those methods, excised or partially disrupted meristems are transformed, subjected to antibiotic or herbicide selection, and then carried through tissue culture to regenerate shoots and roots from the transformed tissues. For non-tissue culture approaches, Agrobacterium or tungsten particles have been used in a number of species to transform cells in or around the apical meristems that are subsequently allowed to grow into plants and produce seeds (Chee and Slighton, 1995; Birch, 1997). However, transformed sectors have typically not persisted into gametes at reasonable frequencies, or the methods have been difficult to reproduce (Birch, 1997). Injection of naked DNA into ovaries has also been reported to produce transformed progeny (Zhou et al., 1983). Variations of this method and “pollen tube pathway” delivery of DNA are still practiced in China (Hu and Wang, 1999). Electroporation-mediated gene transfer into intact meristems in planta and a variety of pollen transformation procedures have also been reported (Chowrira et al., 1995; Touraev et al., 1997 and refs. therein). However, most of these methods have been difficult to reproduce and have not gained widespread acceptance. Early stages of the revolution that transformed Arabidopsis transformation were carried out by Ken Feldmann and David Marks. They applied Agrobacterium to Arabidopsis seeds, grew plants to maturity in the absence of any selection, then collected progeny seeds and germinated them on antibiotic-containing media to identify transformed plants (Feldmann and Marks, 1987; Feldmann, 1992). Although the procedure was difficult to reproduce consistently, successful rounds produced transformants at a high enough rate that thousands of transformed lines were produced in a matter of a few years. These “insertional mutagenesis” lines helped speed gene cloning by the Arabidopsis community (Azpiroz-Leehan and Feldmann, 1997). The lines could be screened for mutant phenotypes of interest and the mutated gene responsible for the phenotype could often be identified by isolation of the Arabidopsis chromosomal DNA flanking the previously known T-DNA (transferred DNA from Agrobacterium). Other laboratories later succeeded in generating transformed Arabidopsis lines by “clip ‘n squirt” methods (Chang et al., 1994;Katavic et al., 1994). Reproductive inflorescences were clipped off,Agrobacterium was applied to the center of the plant rosette, new inflorescences formed a few days later were again removed,Agrobacterium was re-applied, and plants were then allowed to develop and set seed. Transformants were obtained more reliably than with the seed treatment method, but the methods were only marginally more productive than traditional tissue-culture approaches to Arabidopsis transformation (e.g. Valvekens et al., 1988). It's really that simple. For floral dip transformation of Arabidopsis, plants are grown to a stage when they have just started to flower (A), plants are dipped briefly in a suspension of Agrobacterium, Suc, and surfactant (B), plants are maintained for a few more weeks until mature and then progeny seeds are harvested (C), and seeds are germinated on selective medium (e.g. containing kanamycin) to identify successfully transformed progeny (D). The impact of the vacuum infiltration method on Arabidopsis research has been remarkable. Generation of transformed lines is simple and routine (Fig. 1; Bechtold and Pelletier, 1998; Clough and Bent, 1998). First and foremost, barriers to in planta testing of a gene of interest have been dramatically lowered. With minimal effort and in a matter of 3 to 6 months, multiple transgenic plant lines can be constructed and numerous DNA constructs can be tested. A second example of this method’s utility can be seen in positional cloning projects, in which a gene of unknown structure is isolated based on its genetic map position (e.g. Clough et al., 2000). Once a gene has been mapped to a genetic interval of a few centiMorgans, an Arabidopsis chromosome walk can be accelerated by the use of publicly available bacterial artificial chromosome collections. Bacterial artificial chromosome clones containing insert DNAs that span the genomic region can be subcloned into a transformation-competent binary vector, moved into Agrobacterium, and used for “focused shotgun complementation” of a mutant plant line. With the genome sequence available and anchored to genetic maps, researchers may even choose to target their effort to specific candidate genes. The gene of interest is identified by screening sets of transformed plants for individuals that exhibit a corrected phenotype. Another important use of simple, high-throughput transformation returns to the insertional mutagenesis methods pioneered by Feldmann and others. Collections of Arabidopsis containing tens of thousands of independent transformed lines are now available for screening (Azpiroz-Leehan and Feldmann, 1997; Krysan et al., 1999). Researchers alternatively can pursue insertional mutagenesis of a unique plant line, for example to carry out screens for genetic suppressors of a particular mutation. Activationtagging T-DNAs can be used that enhance the expression level of genes near the T-DNA insert, or one can use T-DNAs that place β-glucuronidase (GUS) or other marker genes under the control of host promoter or enhancer elements that may flank the T-DNA at the site of insertion (Weigel et al., 2000). Forward genetic approaches study phenotype first and then genotype, whereas reverse genetic strategies start with a DNA sequence and then seek a plant line mutated in that gene. Efficient transformation methods have facilitated reverse genetic screening in plants. Public collections have been created that allow PCR-based screening of ordered pools of DNA from thousands of transgenic lines (Krysan et al., 1999). Once the subpool of DNA carrying an insert in the gene of interest has been identified, progeny seed corresponding to that pool can be requested. It is important to note that many of these insertional mutagenesis methods can also be accomplished using transposon mutagenesis (e.g. Tissier et al., 1999). A goal for many T-DNA and transposon-mutagenized seedbank collections is to obtain and compile in databases a small stretch of sequence data for the DNA that flanks each insertion (Tissier et al., 1999). This will allow researchers to simply request plant lines that carry a mutation within any DNA sequence in the genome. The above strategies could be extremely useful in research with other plant species. For some species, the current transformation protocols are close to being sufficient (witness the recent production of more than 18,000 fertile transgenic rice lines to form an insertionally tagged population; Jeon et al., 2000). For many important species, however, pursuit of the above strategies would be greatly facilitated by the availability of high-throughput/non-tissue culture transformation methods. After the success of the Arabidopsis vacuum infiltration protocol, a number of laboratories tried to useAgrobacterium vacuum infiltration with other plant species, but failed to obtain transformants. Why? In the absence of a suitable answer, study of the successful Arabidopsis methods was a logical next step. What is the cellular target of transformation? For the Arabidopsis seed transformation and vacuum infiltration methods, it was shown early on that most primary transformants carry hemizygous T-DNA insertion events (Feldmann, 1992; Bechtold et al., 1993). The presence of the T-DNA on only one of two homologous chromosomes implies that productive transformation occurs late in floral development, after the divergence of male and female germ lines (Arabidopsis self-pollinates within individual flowers, and if transformation occurred earlier, selffertilization would be expected to give rise to some homozygous transformants due to presence of the same T-DNA insert in pollen and embryo sac cells). The transformation target is further defined in that transformants obtained from a given plant usually carry independent T-DNA insertion events (Feldmann, 1992;Bechtold et al., 1993). This suggests that transformation occurs after the divergence of individual pollen or egg cell lineages within a flower. A developmental endpoint for the typical target of transformation can also be postulated. Although the result is not as well established, typical primary transformants apparently carry the transgene in all parts of the plant, suggesting that transformation occurred before the cell divisions in a fertilized embryo that establish independent meristems and other distinct adult plant cell lineages. Hence, transformation seems to occur in developing flowers after individual gametophyte cell lineages form, but before extensive development of the embryo. The next question was: Does transformation occur primarily in pollen, ovules, fertilized embryos, or any of the three? It is an interesting historical sidelight that rather than addressing this key question, Arabidopsis researchers in the mid-1990s focused on empirical transformation protocol improvement. Practical motivation to proceed with the generation of transformants was understandably paramount, and overall satisfaction with the new transformation method delayed efforts to understand how it worked. Nevertheless, protocol modifications, ideas, and anecdotal observations were shared widely through meetings, word-of-mouth, and the Arabidopsis electronic newsgroup (http://www.bio.net/hypermail/ Arabidopsis/). Significant findings resulting from this community effort included the discoveries that (a) Plants did not need to be uprooted, treated withAgrobacterium, and re-planted. Transformants could be obtained by treating only the protruding inflorescences; (b) inclusion of Silwet L-77, a strong surfactant that shows relatively low toxicity to plants, often enhanced transformation reliability; and (c) many different Arabidopsis ecotypes were transformable and many differentAgrobacterium strains could be used, although notable differences in efficiency were observed. Most important, the popular name “vacuum infiltration” was superceded when a number of groups found that plants could be transformed when dipped inAgrobacterium solution with no vacuum infiltration. Some workers subsequently moved to spray application ofAgrobacterium rather than dipping. A number of other mechanistic clues and procedural tips were shared (seehttp://www.bio.net/hypermail/Arabidopsis/; Clough and Bent, 1998). A simplified protocol for “floral dip” transformation of Arabidopsis is available athttp://plantpath.wisc.edu/wisc.edu/∼afb/protocol.html. Returning to the question of the cellular target of transformation, three research groups worked in parallel to address this issue and have now published their et al., et al., et al., 2000). that transformation can occur by of flowers in and that and pollen are whereas are it that the male would be the target of However, all three groups found that the female is the primary target of showing the number of Arabidopsis transformants obtained by pollen with pollen or by days to at of after shows that no transformants were obtained Agrobacterium was applied to relatively young flowers that were or more from et al., 2000). of Arabidopsis ovules, embryo and entire due to of an entire with in multiple in a of a showing no or of individual with of sac rather than entire of an entire due to a construct within has the Some from et A different line of also to as the primary site of productive Genetic with a chromosome that most transformants of carry T-DNA on the chromosome set et al., 2000). For the one of events with the chromosome the most was pollen transformation or of T-DNA within the genome of a fertilized embryo. However, the from the efforts of these three seems developing are the primary target of productive transformation in the Arabidopsis floral dip or vacuum infiltration transformation procedures et al., Bechtold et al., et al., 2000). In the above was often only within the embryo sac of ovules, a of transformation late in development (Fig. et al., et al., 2000). transformants were also at a low from of flowers that were developed to pollen and embryo at the or mature stage of development et al., 2000). of entire was suggesting that transformation can also occur in the of the cell (Fig. However, transformation events that give rise to transformed sectors multiple Arabidopsis transformants from the same plant et al., et al., or even from the same et al., are usually This with recent from the legume M. truncatula and the presence of using constructs that are et al., 2000). dip produced the and in of the flower but also produced in which were with (Fig. suggesting that can of Transformants have been obtained from at multiple the et al., et al., 1999). However, transformants in one study were not on a or plant et al., 2000). In study of the more than one and to transformants et al., 2000). In addition, although most on plants no a few multiple et al., 2000). It is that some flowers are particularly to productive transformation events occur in the female one is to how Agrobacterium to that develop within However, Arabidopsis are not The as a of cells that from the floral to form a structure that is at the It is only late in floral development, 3 to that become by of the as a at the of this This with the study (Fig. et al., in which that transformants were all from flowers to to a when the is transformants were obtained from flowers that were or from at the of of occurred only in flowers that were or more to et al., 2000). Agrobacterium apparently Arabidopsis to their of these are that it a number of days to sufficient to to the plant and In addition, the of Bechtold and that transformants can be obtained at a low from of relatively mature flowers suggests that some transformation events may from Agrobacterium by other for example, pollen the however, it is to or to tissue for the Arabidopsis transformation procedures to In a that suggests that transformation of many plant species is within successful transformation of M. truncatula by Agrobacterium vacuum infiltration has been reported et al., 2000). with Arabidopsis, the success plants or However, transformation were reported ranging from to of all seeds et al., 2000). It is that when truncatula plants were transformants homozygous for the transgene were and the of transformants from a given plant were from the same T-DNA M. truncatula transformation can apparently occur at stages of plant development than in Arabidopsis. However, of and of transformants in two were to be showing that multiple transformation events can on a plant even if it is as a et al., 2000). The cellular of these transformation events are not and of these be a high for future In but and obtained transformants only if were subjected to a treatment that The of transformants is not desirable for such as insertional but the overall high of transformation obtained et al., that this method will be of utility to researchers Transformation by infiltration of adult plants has also been reported for et al., and has been reported for other and Arabidopsis. multiple plant species have now been successfully transformed using Agrobacterium in planta In addition, although the methods have not been widely or transformation and methods that tissue culture have been reported for a number of other plant species (Chee and Slighton, and refs. therein). of in planta transformation protocols for other plant species be within Transformation development has been by some as as as but success is most to from efforts by the and (e.g. the of Hansen and Wright, and Birch, 1997). This be with a to different approaches and to the It is that success will be to with some species and than with but are some of the that may to Arabidopsis and M. truncatula are relatively small plants with generation but that may enhance of effort more than success at A high seed set is also to but is not an although single Arabidopsis plants produce to seeds, only or seeds plant were collected in the successful transformation of M. et al., 2000). of such as and of as to can allow in the number of can be important if of success are but can also be a if of treatment is more important than of this are the low success poor that were with Arabidopsis in planta transformation procedures until of plants in flower was The need for of M. truncatula to transformation a variety of approaches may be more productive than with a set of methods. The of the as the site of productive Arabidopsis transformation produces specific for floral transformation efforts with other species. of Agrobacterium to tissues early in their development and to is to be important. In an with some species it may be possible to Agrobacterium by of or by Agrobacterium into flowers using microprojectiles or (e.g. a further plant lines such as the Arabidopsis that a more may an target for transformation et al., 2000). with M. truncatula and Arabidopsis suggests that plants can also be although of after to be In numerous plant transformation the of host Agrobacterium has been an important (Birch, 1997). recent findings with Arabidopsis are any for host and bacterial be focused on assays that transformation of or tissues. With some plant species the use of or other approaches has transformation and many other can be (Birch, 1997; Hansen and Wright, 1999). A understanding of T-DNA transfer and other of (e.g. and Schilperoort, 1992; et al., may also allow of Other different transformation methods also be in (e.g. et al., 1995; et al., 1998). would have that DNA on to particles and then it into plants et al., could be Agrobacterium floral transformation procedures have been a success with Arabidopsis, and success now seems for M. with the recent the for Arabidopsis transformation, a of efforts to these methods to the transformation of other plant species. The are transformation tissue culture can a high method that minimal and of mutagenesis are important, simplified transformation protocols positional insertional and other the effort required to any given DNA construct within plants.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Andrew F. Bent (2000) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: