Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
When someone says, That reminds me of the Neil Simon movie where ... and continues to describe particular circumstance and dialogue, common experience is shared. A message is received. Speaker and listener have mutual understanding of situation. The scene has done its job; it has organized experience in such way to act as metaphor that links real experience to another kind of understanding. What is often forgotten, however, is that the scene from the film is contrived: make-up is in place; clothing is actually costume; scenery is stylized so as to appear 'natural'; the dialogue that appears so natural has been carefully crafted by screenwriter, director, and actors; and spontaneous actions are choreographed. Why is the friend's description of the movie welcomed, and received as almost more real than the lived experience it represents? What power has the scene over the collective imagination and the subsequent renderings of reality? Linda Brodkey (1987) argues that the scene of writing, a solitary writer alone in cold garret working into the small hours of the morning by the thin light of candle, separates the writer from the social processes that surround the practice of writing (p. 396). Like the postcard, the picture of the writer writing alone cuts the writer off from social practices of sharing drafts of texts with readers, talking through problems, and the support of conversation while writing is in process. I raise the question of the composition of the scenes of reading, for like their counterparts in writing, they, too, focus our range of vision turning our attention to specific features. One such picture is the librarian shushing group of animated students, the library place of silence where individuals sit surrounded by piles of books where communication to another is made only through the note slipped across the table. Another picture is the vacationer lazing on beach chair, facing the surf, nose to the thickest of summertime best-sellers. Train conducters collecting tickets from morning commuters with the New York Times and Wall Street Journal opened in V-formation is another picture. The pictures described resonate because they are familiar. They are, with only minor cinemagraphic change, the same scene; reading is often
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Patricia A. Johnston (1989) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: