Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
A night in a typical intensive care unit (ICU) is punctuated by a chorus of alarms, voices, and telephone rings, direct and indirect light pollution, and interruptions from unfamiliar care providers. Poor-quality sleep often results, characterised by frequent disruptions, fragmentation, perturbed circadian rhythms, and a loss of restorative deep stages of sleep 1. As a consequence, critically ill patients report poor sleep as an important source of ICU-related anxiety and stress 2 and list sleep disturbance among the worst memories of their ICU experience 3. Despite this knowledge about poor sleep in the ICU, a large gap exists in our understanding of its effects on patient outcomes. It is widely hypothesised that poor quality of sleep is associated with delirium in the ICU and therefore with the negative consequences of delirium, including prolonged length of stay and long-term physical, cognitive, and psychological sequelae 4. However, previous investigations on this topic were limited in size, enrolled heterogeneous patient populations, and/or were limited by non-validated measures of sleep or delirium 5-9. Recently, promotion of sleep in the ICU has gained increased attention due, in part, to new efforts to minimise the use of sedative medications 10, 11, prevent delirium 12, promote early mobilisation 13 and improve post-ICU neuropsychological outcomes 14. As such, in its recently published Pain, Agitation, and Delirium guidelines, the American College of Critical Care Medicine recommended “promoting sleep in adult ICU patients by optimizing patients' environments, using strategies to control light and noise, clustering patient care activities, and decreasing stimuli at night to protect patient's sleep cycles”, but acknowledged the low quality of evidence supporting this recommendation 15. In this issue of Anaesthesia, Patel and colleagues contribute to the growing literature in this field by evaluating a sleep-promotion and delirium-prevention intervention in a 24-bed mixed medical/surgical ICU in the UK 16. This multi-disciplinary, multi-faceted effort involved both ICU-wide and patient-specific interventions to promote sleep, including minimisation of environmental night-time noise and light, provision of eye masks and earplugs, and clustering of patient care activities, and a delirium-prevention intervention involving daily medication review, pain control, minimisation of sedation, and early mobilisation. Compliance with interventions was optimised using daily prompts and frequent reminders. To implement this intervention, the authors employed a pre/post design, with a 24-day pre-intervention baseline period with data collection on noise, light, sleep and delirium, followed by a 21-day ‘break’ period to allow for adoption of the intervention, and then a 26-day post-intervention period that replicated the baseline data collection. All patients underwent thrice-daily evaluations for sedation and delirium using the Richmond Agitation Sedation Scale (RASS) 17 and Confusion Assessment Method for the ICU (CAM-ICU) 18, respectively. Additionally, a subset of patients without pre-existing sleep or cognitive disorders, neurosurgical admission diagnosis, sedation during the previous 24 hours or delirium during the ICU stay was enrolled consecutively for the sleep assessment, which included a daily Richards-Campbell Sleep Questionnaire (RCSQ) 19 and a one-time Sleep in the ICU Questionnaire (SICUQ) 20. The authors evaluated 167 and 171 patients for delirium assessment during the pre- and post-intervention periods, respectively, and 30 and 29 for the sleep assessment. Of the 338 patients who underwent delirium assessment, 288 (85%) were elective, postoperative admissions to the ICU. The authors reported statistically significant pre- versus post-intervention improvements in the incidence (33% versus 14%, respectively; p < 0.001) and mean duration (3.4 versus 1.2 days, respectively; p = 0.02) of delirium, in the perceived quality of sleep (RCSQ mean score 60.8 versus 75.9, respectively; p < 0.001; SICUQ median ratings 4 versus 7, respectively, p < 0.001), and in the mean night-time noise and light levels, sleep duration, and number of nightly awakenings. Moreover, unadjusted statistical analyses demonstrated that improved sleep efficiency was associated with a reduction in the odds of developing delirium. While this low-cost, multi-faceted intervention demonstrated important potential benefits, the authors appropriately noted several limitations, including a single-centre design, uncertainty of sustainability of the intervention or benefits beyond the 26-day intervention period, and potential bias due to unblinded data collection by staff members who were aware of the intervention. Additionally, the authors highlighted the limitation of using the RCSQ 19, SICUQ 20, and bedside observation to measure sleep, since these instruments have not been validated in heterogeneous ICU populations. Given that polysomnography, the gold standard for sleep measurement, is not feasible for widespread use in the ICU setting, subjective instruments pose a financially and logistically practical alternative for this study design. Further validation of these instruments is warranted, as research on sleep in the ICU continues to grow. In addition, other issues should be considered in reviewing Patel et al.'s study's results. First, there was limited reporting of missing data and no adjustment for potential confounders that differed between the pre- and post-intervention groups. Second, patients were excluded from performing sleep quality assessments if they had known pre-ICU sleep pathology, delirium in the ICU, or had received sedation 24 hours before enrolment. This exclusion helped to support more accurate assessment of patient-perceived quality of sleep in the ICU, but also markedly reduced the sample size and generalisability of the findings. Third, in the statistical analysis, only a single ‘randomly-selected’ sleep assessment was used for each patient, potentially limiting the study's findings. Patel et al. have made an important contribution in building upon previous studies of multi-component interventions to demonstrate further the feasibility and potential benefits of interventions, such as ICU-wide noise and light reduction protocols (e.g. ‘quiet time’ interventions 9, 21-28), earplugs and eye masks 28-31, and relaxation techniques including tranquil music, back massage, and guided imagery 9, 28, 32, 33 (Table1). Notably, the effort by Patel et al. closely paralleled a recent publication by Kamdar et al. 28, which reported on a 145-day, multi-faceted sleep promotion intervention that enrolled 300 patients from a single medical ICU and involved sequential additive interventions involving environmental noise and light reduction, non-pharmacologic interventions (eye masks, earplugs and tranquil music), but also – unlike Patel et al. – included a pharmacologic sleep aid guideline. Both Patel et al. and Kamdar et al. demonstrated significant pre/post improvements in cognitive impairment and perceived noise ratings, and provide evidence of the feasibility and safety of multi-faceted interventions to improve sleep and delirium in the ICU, adding to a growing research foundation to support the design of more rigorous future studies. In summary, Patel et al. should be commended for evaluating a novel multi-faceted intervention to improve sleep and delirium in the ICU, and adding to a growing body of literature on ICU-wide, multi-disciplinary sleep promotion and delirium prevention efforts. Additional studies are needed to advance our understanding of the relationship of ICU-related sleep disruption and delirium. Such efforts are important to evaluate new ideas for improving critically ill patients' short- and long-term physical, cognitive, and mental health outcomes. No external funding and no competing interests declared.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Kamdar et al. (2014) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: