Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
In his recent book, Aquinas and the Ship of Theseus, Christopher Brown has argued that the metaphysics of St. Thomas is preferable to contemporary analytic views because it can solve the problem of material constitution (PMC) without requiring us to relinquish any of the common-sense beliefs that generate that problem. In this critical study, I show that in the case of both substances and aggregates, Browns Aquinas endorses views that are extremely implausible. Consequently, even if it is granted that the solutions to the PMC fall right out of his views, it is still not clear that this gives us reason to prefer his ontology to its competitors. I also consider Brown's take on the status of the human being after death. I do four things in responding to Patrick Toner's incisive critique of my Aquinas and the Ship of Theseus (AST). First, I further motivate Aquinas's position that Socrates exists in the post-mortem and ante-resurrection state by noting that Socrates' situation is at least analogous to other states of affairs that would certainly count as atypical (although not impossible). Secondly, I offer a revised Thomistic account of artefact identity through time in light ofToner's objections to Aquinas's restrictive view. Unlike the restrictive view, this revised account is compatible with common-sense intuitions. Thirdly, I show how my defense of Aquinas's substance metaphysic in AST is useful for the purpose of constructing defeators for certain kinds of arguments for reductionism. Fourthly, I defend Aquinas's views on the unity of substance against Toner's suggestion that they are implausible on the grounds that they are in conflict with certain so-called scientifically informed common-sense beliefs.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Patrick Toner (2007) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: