Why the study?
What is the most accurate method of assessing blood pressure in obese persons?
What is the most accurate method of assessing blood pressure in obese persons?
Accurate blood pressure measurement in obese patients requires individualized cuff sizing based on arm circumference and shape, with forearm or direct intra-arterial measurements serving as necessary alternatives when standard upper arm cuffs are inadequate.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Requires matched cuff sizing for accurate BP in obesity; extends guidelines by specifying forearm and intra-arterial alternatives.
Obesity has reached epidemic proportions worldwide.1 The World Health Organization projects that by 2015 2.3 billion persons will be overweight (body mass index [BMI, calculated as weight in kilograms divided by height in meters squared], 25–29), and another 700 million will be obese (with BMI ≥ 30).2 In the United States alone, more than 78 million adults (35.7%) and 12.5 million children and adolescents (16.9%) are obese.3 As obesity has increased, so has arm circumference, especially to greater than 33 cm. This increasing prevalence creates unique demands for clinicians caring for obese persons across the lifespan in all practice settings. Even basic assessment techniques such as measurement of blood pressure are challenging.4–6Accuracy of blood pressure measurement is contingent on many factors, including correct cuff size and location of measurement.7 According to the American Heart Association (AHA8; Table 1), ideal cuffs have bladder widths at least 40% and lengths 80% of midarm circumference (length to width ratio of 2:1). Therefore, cuff bladders must get longer and wider as arm circumference increases; otherwise mismatching may occur. The most common mismatch is using small or short cuffs (bladder too small).9 Such “undercuffing” leads to overestimates of systolic blood pressure (SBP) and diastolic blood pressure (DBP; range of error, 2.4–30 mm Hg), resulting in erroneous classification of patients as hypertensive, leading to unnecessary therapy.8–10In addition to arm circumference, researchers in a recent study determined that upper arms are troncoconical in shape (obese or not).11 Differences between proximal and distal upper arm circumference ranged from 1 to 20 cm, with a mean of 8.7 cm. Although sex and degree of obesity influenced shape, arm circumference was the factor that most significantly influenced conicity index. Increased conicity associated with obesity (or muscularity) can result in poor cuff fit.12 To complicate matters more, obese patients of small stature may have short upper arms.10 Thus, if cuffs that are too wide are used (bladders too large), arm length poses a problem. Although thigh cuffs may be the best fit for the arm circumference, the distal cuff end will be too long, extending past the elbow/antecubital fossa. This situation results in “overcuffing,” which yields a false underestimate of blood pressure (range of error, 10–30 mm Hg).9,10 These anatomic challenges and the many cuff choices are compounded by the potential lack of consistent use of a particular cuff size between clinicians, further reducing the reliability of blood pressure values that guide critical treatment decisions. As a result, the following PICO (population, intervention, control, and outcomes) question was chosen for this clinical review: What is the most accurate method of assessing blood pressure in obese persons?A search of the MEDLINE and CINAHL databases, limited to the past 10 years, was conducted with the following search terms: obese, overweight, blood pressure monitoring, cuff size, and conical shaped.Eleven observational studies were retrieved (Table 2). In 2 studies,11,13 cuff types were compared (standard vs large, rigid cylindrical vs conical); in 3 studies,4,17,21 blood pressure measurements obtained via direct intra-arterial vs ausculatory/oscillometric techniques were compared; and in 6 studies,14–16,18–20 blood pressure measurements obtained from the upper arm versus the forearm were compared.Existing evidence on blood pressure assessment in obese persons is at level C (Table 3). Not surprisingly, current evidence suggests that when vital decisions are required in the treatment of critically ill obese patients, direct intra-arterial measurement of blood pressure should be used instead of ausculatory/oscillometric techniques, which are associated with significant error.4,17A second recommendation relates to matching cuffs with the size and shape of the upper arm. Preferably on admission, clinicians should measure the arm circumference midway between the shoulder and elbow and evaluate the shape of the upper arm. Based on size and shape dimensions, an appropriately sized cuff as closely aligned to the AHA’s guidelines as possible should be selected. This assessment is essential as evidence shows that standard cuffs yield overestimates of blood pressure in obese persons13 compared with larger appropriately sized cuffs.Although the AHA recommends long cuffs with large arm circumferences and short upper arms,8 McFarlane10 points out that these cuffs do not meet the bladder size standard because only the outside cuff material is extra long. Indeed, Watson et al20 reported that extra-long cuffs used on the upper arm in patients with large arm circumferences were associated with significantly higher SBP (compared with standard cuffs). In an unpublished study, McFarlane compared blood pressure measurements obtained in the forearm and upper arm using extra-long versus appropriately-sized cuffs in patients with BMIs of 36 to 40.10 Blood pressure was overestimated with the extra long cuff. Additionally, forearm blood pressure was closer to values obtained with a properly sized cuff on the upper arm (vs measurements with extra long cuffs).Consequently, the forearm should be used when cuffs cannot be fitted correctly because upper arm circumferences are greater than 50 cm, or conical arms do not permit cuffs to wrap straight across the arm. To assess blood pressure at the forearm, use a standard adult cuff (wrists are more consistently cylindrical even in obese persons) centered between the elbow and wrist. Support the forearm at the level of the heart and (1) palpate the radial artery; (2) listen to sounds over the radial artery; or (3) use a Doppler probe, oscillometric device (with hoses exiting over radial artery), or validated wrist monitor.7,8,18 When assessing blood pressure at alternative locations, it is essential to recognize that blood pressure varies appreciably in different parts of the arterial system, with SBP increasing in more distal arteries and DBP decreasinig.23 Thus, because measurements of blood pressure in the forearm generally yield overestimates of SBP, DBP, and mean arterial pressure (MAP) compared with the upper arm (reported variances, 2.3–27 mm Hg),10,14,19–21,24,25 it is important to decide what discrepancy is clinically acceptable.10,14,20 As McFarlane10 described, a difference of ±5 mm Hg (standard deviation ≤8 mm Hg) is the standard used by the International Standards Organization and manufacturers that test noninvasive devices for measuring blood pressure against mercury sphygmomanometers.Other considerations in blood pressure measurement may also come into play. Blood pressure should not be measured on the upper arm on the same surgical side as a mastectomy to prevent lymphedema, or when an arteriovenous shunt/fistula or vascular access device is present. Thus, depending on the clinical situation, blood pressure in obese persons may need to be evaluated at the calf or thigh by using an appropriately sized cuff for the extremity. The lower edge of the cuff should be positioned 2.5 cm above the malleoli (calf) or 2 to 3 cm above the popliteal fossa (thigh).7In conclusion, consistent use of methods for measuring blood pressure is imperative for accurate assessment and treatment of obese patients.7 Once a method has been established for each individual patient, the specifics for blood pressure assessment must be communicated across the care team, including cuff size and location. This communication is critical to ensure that clinicians on different shifts or in different units or departments use similar techniques and thus reduce potential variations that can be introduced when various sizes of blood pressure cuffs or various locations are used.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Margo A. Halm (2014) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: