Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
MAX SCHELER: ON THE GROUND OF CHRISTIAN THOUGHT I Max Scheler, one of the major contemporary European philosophers, was born in Munich in 1874 of a Protestant father and a Jewish mother. Early in life he became a convert to Catholicism. In the writings of the first two periods of his scholarly life, from 1900—1922, Scheler was influenced by Catholicism. On the Eternal in Man, the fifth volume of the collected works, is a representative production of these first two periods . However, Scheler found himself in growing disagreement with the Church and its doctrine during the third period of his scholarlylife, which dates approximately from 1922—1928. It is not surprising, therefore, that many Catholic writers have emphasized Scheler's "Catholic period", and have tended to ignore his last period of philosophical inquiry. Yet Scheler's writings from all periods of his life have had great impact on contemporary thought. Indeed because of this influence, we wish to examine in this paper some of the basic ideas which have contributed to his understanding of Christianity and the nature of Christian thought. Initially we should note that Scheler agrees with nearly every representative of the phenomenological and existential movement in Europe, that a Christian philosophy as such does not exist and never has existed. Like his close friend, Martin Heidegger, who compares the notion of Christian philosophy to a square circle because reason (philosophy ) and genuine faith (religion) are different in essence1, Scheler argues similarly, namely, that an act of thinking and an act of faith are phenomenologically (i. e. in consciousness-of) different. For whereas an act of philosophical reasoning does not imply divine response, acts of faith (e. g. praying, living, petitioning, worshiping, thanking) must always imply the experience of a divine response. A religious act is, therefore, a receiving act, awaiting the response of the divine. This is true not only in the Christian religion, but also in any religion. Indeed if divine response as a correlate of the religious act is not experienced, Scheler argues, there is not a religious act present. 1 Heidegger, Nietzsche, II, p. 132. 12 Franciscan Studies 1967 178MANFRED FRINGS In contrast to this, Aristotle's notion of an ens a se is clearly metaphysical , since it excludes any possible religious experience of faith and response of a personal God. Hence the ens a se is defined in Greek thought as an object of reasoning, as ???s?? ???se??, or pure thought. There is no indication in Aristotle's philosophy, for example, that there is a response on the part of the Self-Thinking Thought. Consequently, the ens a se pertains only to metaphysics. According to Scheler, a strict phenomenological distinction must be made between acts of rational insight into the ens a se and religious acts of consciousness directed to a personal God. Scheler developed his phenomenological presentation of religious acts as distinct from acts of thinking in his work, On the Eternal in Man. His analysis of the concept of Christian philosophy in its modern controversial form is both historical and philosophical. Indeed it is the historical facts of its development which underlie the modern conception of Christian philosophy. Supposedly Christian philosophy originated in the Middle Ages; yet Medieval philosophy is anything but a unified whole. Not only were there several influential schools of thought which developed somewhat independently of each other, but these schools also frequently contradicted each other, e. g. the Augustinian, the Thomistic, and the Scotistic schools. In each of these schools the primacy of love or intellect or will received very different explanations, and this led to different philosophical results. But it is the philosophy of St. Thomas and its Aristotelian implications particularly, which Scheler opposed. For Scheler, the Aristotelianization of the new Christian event (i. e. love) is a totally inadequate undertaking for Christian philosophy. Because a reputed Christian philosophy, such as that of St. Thomas, has retained the conceptualization of man as animal rationale, its understanding of Christian man is inadequate. Thus, Scheler recognizes only the rudimentary beginnings of a genuine Christian philosophy in the works and exemplary lives of St. Augustine, St. Bernard of Clairvaux, St. Francis, Pascal, and Malebranche.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Manfred S. Frings (1967) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: