Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
In 1854, the Suzhou Pans, one of the most prestigious and powerful lineages in this city during the Qing period, compiled their first genealogy. Counting from the first generation Pan Jingwen (1639–1706), who settled in Suzhou as a salt merchant during the beginning of the dynasty, the Pans had been living in this city for about 200 years. Between 1769 and the time of this compilation, they had produced eight jinshi degree holders, including the grand secretary Pan Shi'en (1769–1854). However, strikingly enough, the genealogy was not prefixed with their place name Suzhou, as were most of the genealogies compiled in Ming and Qing China. Instead, it bears the title "Branch Genealogy of the Pans of Dafu"—Dafu being a village in Huizhou Prefecture from whence Pan Jingwen, the first settler, migrated two centuries before. Continuing to produce high degree holders in the civil service examinations and maintaining their reputation and influence in Suzhou, the Pans compiled four more genealogies up to the early twentieth century, all bearing the same title. The latest edition of their genealogy, still bearing the same title, was compiled in 1992, sponsored by the Pan descendants living in the U.S. What deserves our attention is more than the title of the genealogies. Agnates included in the genealogies were mainly the Pans of Suzhou, yet they also included a group of Pans living in Huizhou: the descendents of Jingwen's second son Zhaochen (1664–1735) who later moved back to the homeland while his eight brothers all remained in Suzhou. About twenty years before the compilation of their first genealogy, the Pans of Suzhou also incorporated a lineage estate—the Songlin Estate (yizhuang)—in 1832 under the initiation and leadership of Zunqi (1808–1892, jinshi of 1848), who was also the genealogy compiler. Managed jointly by agnates from both Huizhou and Suzhou, the Songlin Estate provided financial aid to both the Pans of Suzhou [End Page 31] and agnates from Huizhou sojourning in Suzhou. The estate also continuously funded lineage construction back in Huizhou by pouring resources into the renovation of ancestral halls and the maintenance of the lineage graveyard. In the 1880s, the Suzhou Pans also made it a rule to send Suzhou agnates back to Dafu village every two to three years for the purpose of sweeping the ancestral graves and participating in ancestral sacrifices. According to one of the lineage leaders, this was to remind the Pan descendants in Suzhou of their ancestral roots in Huizhou.1 By the time the first genealogy was compiled in 1854, the Pans of Suzhou can be regarded as a lineage by any definition of this oft-debated term.2 However, the most striking feature of the Pans' lineage practice—its involvement with two distant places—has not been adequately accounted for in current studies on Chinese lineage. It is this characteristic of the Pans' lineage practice and its impact on the Pan descendants' identity formation that constitute the subject of this article. Since many merchant families, especially those from Huizhou, had experiences comparable to the Pans, a study of the Pans' lineage practice will illuminate the complexity of the interactions between kinship practice, spatial mobility, and identity formation in Ming-Qing China. Studies of Chinese Lineage: Local and Translocal As has been widely recognized by historians as well as anthropologists, lineage organizations or, to a larger extent, kinship ties in general, played an important role in various aspects of late imperial Chinese society. Following the paradigmatic construction of Maurice Freedman, whose investigations of lineage organization in the 1950s centered on patrilineal descent and corporate property ownership, social anthropologists produced numerous scholarly works in the following two decades examining the structure and formation of lineages in China.3 Social historians joined the discussion on this topic in the late 1970s, and helped to move the discussion from the Freedmanian focus on [End...
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Yongtao Du (2006) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: