Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The Fields and Perrott test, originally devised as a test for allophane, has been shown to give a positive test with soil materials having reactive Al(OH) x . This includes the Bf horizon of Podzols. In the test, a drop of saturated NaF solution is added to approximately 10 mg of soil on a spot test plate. After 2 min, the pH of the suspension, as measured with narrow range pH paper, divided a variety of B horizons into two groups. The Bf horizons gave pH values above 10.3 whereas Bm, Bg or Bt horizons all yielded pH values below 10.2 with this field test. The C horizons of a number of Podzols yielded a variety of pH values but the values were all low in the Ae and high in the B horizons. This grouping was found to be a funtion of the content of oxalate-extractable Al. Ground gibbsite, amorphous Al(OH) 3 , allophane, synthetic dioctahedral chlorite and Bf horizons which had greater than 1% oxalate-extractable Al yielded pH values in 1 M NaF solution of 11.0 or higher. Therefore, the Fieldes and Perrott test cannot be considered as a specific test for allophane.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Brydon et al. (1970) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: