Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Humanities instruction within STEM-oriented programmes often encounters reduced student engagement, partly reflecting misalignment between disciplinary reasoning norms and instructional framing. This study conceptualises epistemic alignment as an instructional-design construct through which instructional discourse reflects the analytical reasoning practices characteristic of STEM learning environments. A semester-long quasi-experimental crossover design was conducted with 120 undergraduate engineering students enrolled in a compulsory English course. Two intact sections received contrasting instructional framings, epistemically aligned and traditional humanities-oriented, with conditions reversed during a planned crossover module. Lesson-specific engagement was measured across five instructional units, general course engagement was assessed using pre–post surveys, and comprehension was evaluated through structured analytic assessments. Results revealed a significant Section × Unit interaction for lesson-specific engagement, F (3.86, 454.96) = 7.47, p < .001, η ²ₚ = .060, indicating that engagement trajectories were dynamically responsive to instructional framing and shifted during the crossover phase. Students exposed to epistemically aligned instruction generally reported higher levels of engagement and moderate advantages in comprehension across several instructional units, with these patterns reversing under the alternate framing condition. General course engagement increased over time, F (1,118) = 11.41, p < .001, η ²ₚ = .088, with descriptive patterns suggesting somewhat greater gains under aligned instruction. Moderation analysis further indicated that epistemic orientation was more strongly associated with engagement within epistemically aligned contexts. These findings offer a perspective that reconceptualises engagement as an epistemically situated and dynamically responsive process rather than a stable learner attribute or purely motivational outcome. This perspective highlights how instructional design, aligned with disciplinary modes of reasoning, may be associated with learners’ engagement and comprehension in STEM-oriented language classrooms.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Panchal et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: