Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Dignity lies at the heart of our shared humanity. The Latin root of the word dignity, dignitātem, suggesting “merit” and “worth,” originally applied to persons of noble birth, or persons holding high rank. To this day, we sometimes equate dignity with social standing and bearing. However, enlightenment-era thinking transformed our understanding of dignity to embrace the idea that all people hold special standing by virtue of our shared humanity. This principle was eventually embedded in the 1948 United Nations Universal Declaration of Human Rights, which opens with a preamble that says, “Whereas recognition of the inherent dignity and of the equal and inalienable rights of all members of the human family is the foundation of freedom, justice and peace in the world”—effectively centering dignity in the global human rights agenda, as part of “a common standard of achievement for all peoples and all nations.” Thinking about dignity in this manner has powerful implications. It motivates us to transcend factors—be they race, ethnicity, social class, sex—that may otherwise divide us, and pushes us to ensure that treating all persons with respect becomes a core goal for our actions. Dignity is not often thought of as a core goal of health, medicine, or health systems, but there is ample reason to suggest that it should be and a body of writing about dignity in patient care to draw on. Although the word “dignity” does not appear in Peabody’s classic article,1 he did note that “When a patient enters a hospital, one of the first things that commonly happens to him is that he loses his personal identity”—cautioning that clinicians often lose sight of the patient by overly focusing on the organ. More recent work offers prescriptions for how to orient clinical care toward preserving dignity for patients, including the importance of physician attitude and behaviors in such efforts.2 There is also a literature about the role of dignity in palliative care,3,4 and evidence that treating patients with dignity and respect improves patient satisfaction and clinical outcomes.5 These strands remind us that even if a patient’s dignity is sometimes lost in the transactions of clinical care and the urgent press to ensure treatment, our shared humanity remains important. Recognizing dignity at the core of the human experience should be a powerful motivation for those working to promote health and should help align priorities for both clinical care and health promotion. The importance of dignity, however, has not always been recognized throughout history, and our actions in the face of COVID-19 suggest that we have, at best, a tenuous grip on ensuring dignity as a core aspiration. For example, in the US and in other countries worldwide, hospitals aiming to limit spread of COVID-19 imposed restrictions on family members visiting dying loved ones or access to caregivers for people with disabilities.6,7 There is a growing literature that is beginning to assess the nonhealth consequences associated with many of the actions taken throughout 2020 to preserve health in the context of a global pandemic,8 and it seems fitting at this moment to pause and reaffirm both the centrality of dignity to the health enterprise and to articulate how to ensure that this core aspiration is reflected both in our day-to-day work and when faced with crises. Three thoughts emerge as central learnings from the moment. First, any reckoning with how well the health system has performed during the COVID-19 pandemic must take into account consequences well beyond our clinical handling of the infection itself. Although the news media were preoccupied for most of 2020 with COVID-19 case counts, those of us engaged in health care should recognize that preserving health—and the dignity of people Author affiliations and article information are listed at the end of this article.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Sandro Galea (2021) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: