Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Some reported counts of species abundances, when tallied by octaves or other appropriate intervals, do not conform at all well to the expected normal (lognormal) distribution, but the departures therefrom seem to be by no means systematic or consistent. In the present paper we examine briefly two examples: The Audubon Christmas Bird Counts, and the counts of diatoms in freshwater streams. In some cases the departure may be due to defective, nonrandom, sampling; in others to using more than one method of sampling and then confounding the samples; in still others the sampling may be satisfactory, but the "universe" that is sampled may itself be a hybrid one, two universes (or more than two) interpenetrating one another. In the tropics the distribution of birds is lognormal but not canonical. Here the explanation must be different. The sigma values are far too low. I call these "congested" distributions. Biologically it may mean that there are more species than niches, a presumably unstable situation, possibly arising from recent (Pleistocene?) excessive speciation. Apparently some problems exist that deserve examination.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
F. W. Preston (1980) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: