Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
We read with interest the article by Teoh et al. [1] comparing intubating characteristics of three different videolaryngoscopes with those of the Macintosh laryngoscope. Videolaryngoscopy is becoming increasingly popular, especially to aid tracheal intubation in patients with difficult airways. Like Mines and Ahmad [2], we have concerns about the use of the Cormack–Lehane grading system during videolaryngoscopy as a clinical information sharing tool. When Cormack and Lehane originally designed their grading system more than two decades ago, their purpose was to encourage training and to aid decision-making during direct laryngoscopy [3]. Cormack has reinforced this issue in recent correspondence [4]. Since then, the system has become widely used on anaesthetic charts to aid subsequent anaesthetists with decision-making and planning. Although not designed as an information sharing tool, the Cormack–Lehane grading has served this purpose well for direct laryngoscopy. However, we feel it is not an appropriate tool for information sharing for videolaryngoscopy. During direct laryngoscopy, the larynx is viewed from outside the oral cavity. The distance between the object (vocal cords) and the viewer (laryngoscopist’s eye), and the angle of view (15–30°), contribute to the restricted view. During videolaryngoscopy, a camera or a viewing lens is situated near the tip of the laryngoscope blade and near the larynx, with an angle of view of 50–60°. With these advantages, the view using videolaryngoscopy is almost certain to be better than with direct laryngoscopy. Many studies have demonstrated that videolaryngoscopy improves the view; however, this does not always translate into easier tracheal intubation [5, 6]. Regarding research studies of videolaryngoscopy, the intubation difficulty scale (IDS), proposed by Adnet et al. [7], could be considered. It incorporates seven separate variables and captures indices of difficulty common to both direct and indirect laryngoscopes. It is, however, a complex scoring system and may not be as useful clinically as an information sharing tool. Videolaryngoscopes all vary slightly in design and function, and so developing a single robust scoring system may not be possible. Instead, we recommend concise documentation to aid future anaesthetic management, which should include: (i) name and size of the videolaryngoscope; (ii) grade/experience of the laryngoscopist; (iii) number of attempts; (iv) optimising position/use of adjuncts; and (v) easy/difficult/failed intubation. No external funding or no competing interests declared. Previously posted at the Anaesthesia Correspondence website: http://www.anaesthesiacorrespondence.com
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Angadi et al. (2011) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: