Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Arguably, the earliest moment at which one might look for a reception of the Roman Republican senate is in the early Imperial age. For if we regard the term ‘Republican’ as designating a particular era and a particular governmental regime, it seems to me that this period and regime must be seen to be over and closed before the question can be posed as to how a governmental organ like the senate functioned, or what its characteristics were, under those circumstances. In this article, I seek to identify some aspects of an early Imperial reception of the Republican senate, focusing in particular on the writings of Tacitus and Pliny the Younger — both senators themselves, writing in the early decades of the second century CE under the emperor Trajan and thus more than a century removed from the fall of the Republic. I begin by discussing the problematic terms ‘Republican’ and ‘Imperial’, and the knotty questions of periodization and perspective that they raise. I then sketch the characteristics of the early Imperial senate — the phase of this body described by Pliny and Tacitus and in which they participated — with attention to its similarities to and differences from the late Republican senate. I proceed to discuss the perspective Tacitus presents in his Annales on the senate of the Julio-Claudian age, the emperor’s role in the senate’s operations, and the body’s relationship (as far as he makes this clear) to its pre-Imperial counterpart. Then, I examine Pliny’s quite different perspective on senate’s operations in his own day, and on the emperor’s role therein, as described in his Epistulae. To conclude, I consider the implications of Pliny’s and Tacitus’ perspectives for the question of senatorial continuity and change, for the validity of the Republic-Empire periodization, and hence for the very possibility of a ‘reception’ of the Republican senate in the Imperial age.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Matthew B. Roller (2014) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: