Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
In this paper, I reconsider the notion of agency often neglected in contemporary moral theory. More specifically, I examine what the taking place between the physician and the patient entails from a moral perspective. The discipline of medical ethics focuses mostly on the four principles of autonomy, justice, nonmaleficence, and beneficence as the foundational precepts guiding the physician through a consultation. However, the nature of medical practice, i.e., medicine as moral practice, requires a much richer vision of the reality of moral life. The physician, due to his or her special status, is de facto liable as a moral agent because of the fiduciary nature of the with the patient and the kind of knowledge he or she possesses. In other words, although medicine requires scientific and technological knowledge, it is first and foremost oriented towards what Edmund D. Pellegrino calls a healing relationship that demands moral accountability. In the last four decades, the progress of medicine has increasingly challenged ethicists, physicians, theologians, and philosophers to provide justifications of new medical innovations. Some very important issues, such as organ transplants, abortion, physician assisted suicide, genetic manipulation, IVF technologies, and cloning have moved to the center of political and public discussions as never before. In the 1960s, in response to the increasing social concern about the moral implications of these new enhancements in medicine, physicians turned to lay peoplemostly theologians, philosophers and lawyersto consider the morality of particular issues. This shift in prerogative gave birth to the discipline of bioethics. 1 Although many streams of influence shaped this new form of moral philosophy from its beginnings, todays most dominant form of moral reasoning encountered within the field of bioethics is oriented toward examining quandaries and act analysis. In the following essay I do not aim to critique such methodology per se but rather consider one aspect that is often disregarded in bioethical theory, that is, the importance of agency in moral reasoning and how it relates to medical practice. This is for one specific reason.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
A 2001 study studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 9 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: