Key result
A Delphi survey of 39 expert stakeholders established consensus for minimum impairment criteria for impaired muscle power, range of motion, leg length difference, hypertonia, and ataxia.
Why the study?
The International Paralympic Committee mandates defined minimum impairment criteria for sports, but consensus on these criteria was needed for wheelchair basketball.
A Delphi survey established stakeholder consensus for minimum impairment criteria in wheelchair basketball for several impairments, highlighting the need for further quantitative research and feasibility testing.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
May inform wheelchair basketball classification standards; leaves open prospective validation of competitive equity.
The International Paralympic Committee athlete classification code mandates sports to have defined minimum impairment criteria, describing the minimum level of an eligible impairment an athlete must possess, to be able to participate in that sport. The aim of this study was to establish stakeholders' consensus for the minimum impairment criteria in wheelchair basketball. From a pool of 48 expert stakeholders (identified via an international medical and scientific working group), 39 completed a 4-round Delphi survey. Questions were answered on the method of assessing each eligible impairment, and the level of impairment that should constitute the minimum impairment criteria. This study indicated where stakeholder consensus existed and noted that consensus was developed for impaired muscle power, impaired passive range of motion, leg length difference, hypertonia and ataxia. No consensus was found for limb deficiency and athetosis. Participants raised concerns with using subjective measurement scales for assessing certain impairments, whilst also calling for more quantitative research to be conducted into the level of impairment that should constitute the minimum impairment criteria. For these research findings to form practical minimum impairment criteria that are part of a wheelchair basketball classification system, it is required to examine their feasibility by conducting further research.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Hutchinson et al. (2022) studied Wheelchair basketball minimum impairment criteria (n=39). Delphi survey was evaluated on Consensus on the method of assessing each eligible impairment and the level of impairment constituting minimum impairment criteria. A Delphi survey of 39 expert stakeholders established consensus for minimum impairment criteria for impaired muscle power, range of motion, leg length difference, hypertonia, and ataxia.
Synapse has enriched 5 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: