Key result
Conservative management of chronic left ventricular pseudoaneurysm in elderly adults yielded a mean survival of 124 months, suggesting surgical repair may not be indicated.
Why the study?
Does conservative management provide acceptable long-term survival in elderly adults with chronic left ventricular pseudoaneurysm?
Does conservative management provide acceptable long-term survival in elderly adults with chronic left ventricular pseudoaneurysm?
Conservative management of chronic left ventricular pseudoaneurysm in elderly patients may be associated with a benign long-term course and acceptable survival without cardiac rupture.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
May support conservative management in select elderly cases; leaves open whether surgery improves survival.
To the Editor: Cardiac pseudoaneurysm is an infrequent form of cardiac rupture contained by adherent pericardium or scar tissue, usually caused by myocardial infarction (MI). The absence of myocardium increases the risk of rupture and death.1 It can also be associated with heart failure and embolic events,2 as happens with true ventricular aneurysm. Most investigators support surgical management3, 4 because of a 30% to 45% risk of rupture.1, 5 Because the epidemiology and treatment of cardiovascular disease have changed, knowledge of the natural history of this rare cardiac complication is limited.6 Management of chronic pseudoaneurysm in a public hospital without a cardiac surgery unit, the only hospital serving a population of approximately 260,000, was reviewed. A search was conducted using the terms “pseu-doaneurysm” and “false aneurysm” from 1995 to 2012. After careful review of clinical records and cardiac images, six cases of chronic pseudoaneurysm were confirmed. Vital status was investigated, and cumulative survival rates were analyzed using Kaplan–Meier curves. Mean age at the time of diagnosis was 80 (range 67–94). All cases were secondary to MI. Two were diagnosed in the acute phase, one was found 7 years after the MI episode, and three were incidental findings. Of these, two were asymptomatic individuals studied because they had an abnormal electrocardiogram, and the other was a 94-year-old individual admitted because of syncope. All these incidentally found pseudoaneurysms were associated with previous chronic silent MI, two undated and one perioperative. Of the three related to nonsilent MI, one received fibrinolysis. The other two individuals came to the hospital 48 and 96 hours after the onset of chest pain. Figure 1 shows diagnostic images of a 79-year-old asymptomatic individual with a silent undated MI, who was alive at the time this letter was written. None of the individuals underwent surgery; four refused surgery and it was not offered in two because of age and comorbidity. Three individuals died at a mean age of 90 (range 82–95) after a mean follow up of 113 months (range 29–158). Cancer, stroke, and sudden death were the causes of death. Three patients were alive (mean survival 33 months, range 14–55). Survival for the whole group was of 124 months (95% confidence interval = 58–189). Survival was 100% at 1 year and 75% at 4 years of follow-up. This experience shows a long mean survival in a group of elderly adults with chronic pseudoaneurysms who did not undergo surgery, half of the pseudoaneurysms were incidentally found after silent MI. This finding contrasts with the common recommendation of surgery,1, 3, 5 which was suggested after a review of 23 cases.7 That study argued that “rupture is fatal,” but the data were not convincing; two of six individuals who underwent surgery died, and four of 12 who did not had ventricular rupture, a 33% incidence of death for each group. In other series,6 19% of patients did not have surgery, and none of them suffered ventricular rupture during follow-up. In a recent series of nine chronic pseudoaneurysms that were not repaired,8 none of the individuals died from cardiac rupture, and the 4-year cumulative survival rate was 74.1%. The current series was a small retrospective one, which limits the value of Kaplan–Meyer analysis, but most knowledge about the management of pseudoaneurysms is based on collections of cases or small single-center experiences. The individuals included in this sample were not representative of the whole population of individuals with MI; they were elderly, and most of them came to the hospital very late or did not come during the acute episode. None was treated with mechanical reperfusion therapy, which reduces the risk of cardiac rupture.9 They were survivors. Maintained normal physical activity after a MI could increase the risk of cardiac rupture because of an increase in stress on the damaged ventricular wall. This would happen more easily after silent MI, which is more frequent in elderly adults.10 This, and not only a more-conservative surgical attitude, could help explain why chronic pseudoaneurysms are more frequent in elderly adults and explains the frequent presentation as an incidental finding: 50% in our series and 48% in others.6 The long-term course of chronic ventricular pseudoaneurysm can be considered to be benign. Incidental finding of this entity is frequent in elderly adults, and surgical repair is not indicated in older, asymptomatic, or high-risk individuals. The authors are grateful to Hugh Ahern, medical student at the University of Alcalá (Alcalá de Henares, Madrid, Spain), for the care with which he reviewed the original manuscript.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
García‐Lledó et al. (2014) conducted a letter in Chronic left ventricular pseudoaneurysm (n=6). Conservative management (no surgery) was evaluated on Mean survival (95% CI 58-189). Conservative management of chronic left ventricular pseudoaneurysm in elderly adults yielded a mean survival of 124 months, suggesting surgical repair may not be indicated.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: