Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
We formerly believed that in cases of ependymoma radiation therapy should be directed only to residual tumor and the tumor bed. Experience has taught us that this precept is wrong. Complete surgical tumor removal is unusual in ependymoma (4, 6), making the addition of postoperative radiation therapy desirable. Reports by Bouchard and Peirce (1), Kricheff et al. (4), and Phillips et al. (6) suggest that long-term survival free of disease is greater when radiation therapy is added than when operative removal is the only treatment (2, 7). Knowledge of the incidence of implantation along the subarachnoid space by tumor cells floating in the cerebrospinal fluid would settle the question of whether irradiation should be confined to the tumor bed or should be administered to the entire cerebrospinal fluid axis. This knowledge is not available, although the development of new cytologic technics for examination of the cerebrospinal fluid may soon provide the answer. Review of the Literature Spiller (8) reported the first case of seeding of ependymoma in 1907. Subsequent reports (3, 9, 10) indicated an incidence of seeding of 31–43 per cent and suggested that irradiation encompass the cerebrospinal fluid pathway. In contrast with this high incidence, most recent reports (1, 4, 6) advise against irradiation of the cerebrospinal fluid axis because of the low incidence, 2–3 per cent, of seeding in series of 12 (1), 65 (4), and 42 (6) patients. Present Experience All cases diagnosed as ependymoma at the Stanford University Medical Center, Palo Alto, Calif., between January 1956 and June 1964 were reviewed by the authors. The histologic criteria defined by Mabon et al. (5) were satisfied in 14. Of the 14 patients, 6 were male and 8 were female. The age at onset of symptoms ranged from one week to fifty-three years. Six were less than ten years of age, 3 were between eleven and twenty years, and 5 were more than twenty-one years old (Fig. 1). Presenting signs and symptoms were those of a mass lesion in a segment of the central nervous system and were not specific for ependymoma. Symptoms were present for one week to ten years before diagnosis, the average delay in intracranial tumors being six months, with a range of one to eighteen months. Longer symptomatic periods, up to ten years, were found in spinal canal tumors. Primary tumor localization was supra-tentorial in 4 cases, infratentorial in 7, and in the spinal canal in 3 (Fig. 2). Three patients were seen at Stanford University only after recurrence. The original diagnosis was made and the treatment given elsewhere. In one instance, an infant of one week, the diagnosis could not be made until postmortem examination at three months. All other patients were treated by surgical removal of as much tumor as possible, followed by x-ray therapy to the residual tumor and tumor bed, except for the 3 latest. These received therapy to the entire cerebrospinal fluid axis.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Sagerman et al. (1965) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: