Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
NEGLIGENT HIRING: HEADACHES FOR THE SMALL BUSINESSPERSON There continues to be a large number of lawsuits challenging employer hiring practices in the United States today. Often the basis of these lawsuits is a claim that in the hiring process the employer was negligent in some way in making employment decisions. The alleged negligence may arise from the employer's failure to make sufficient inquiry when hiring an employee or additionally may arise if the employer retains an employee when he or she knew or should have known that the employee might have the propensity to injure another person. A pattern has evolved from the multitude of recent cases that will help the small business employer identify and avoid potential problems in the hiring, training, supervision, and retention of employees. Let us assume that a small business owner is seeking to fill a job position in which the new employee will have a great deal of contact with the public. The owner narrows her decision to one candidate and decides to hire him. The owner very much likes the job candidate and because of time constraints and other priorities sees no need to contact references or former employers. In particular, the business owner decides not to investigate a six-month gap in the job candidate's employment history. The candidate is hired and begins work with zeal. However, after four months of calling on customers, the employee assaults and batters a prospective customer. It seems the two had gotten into an argument and a fight had ensued. The prospective customer sues the employer, and wins. It is brought to public attention for the first time at trial that the employee had been fired from a previous job for this same type of incident and had been unemployed for six months (the gap in the employment history on the application). It is also indicated at trial that had the present employer investigated the new hire's background, she would have discovered this information and the fact that, when under extreme stress, the new employee had a tendency toward violence, if provoked. Incidents quite similar to the one described above have occurred and resulted in successful cases against small business people. The small business owner should understand the basis of negligent hiring, liability, the process for defending such claims, and how to avoid such potential lawsuits. THE BASIS OF LIABILITY Application of the law of negligence to the activities of hiring or retaining employees is well-recognized. It is an established basis of recovery for personal injuries and is defined as the failure of a person to exercise that degree of skill or care usually exercised by a reasonable person under similar circumstances. Originally, negligent hiring claims were filed by employees who claimed employers had failed to provide a safe work environment which, in turn, resulted in some injury to the employee. A safe work environment was understood to include having competent and well-trained co-workers. If the employer breached this duty by hiring an unfit worker, an employee injured by his co-worker could recover for his employer's negligence. Today this type of lawsuit would most likely be handled by workers' compensation courts. The elements of negligence in such cases are relatively straightforward. The employer owed his employee a duty to provide a safe workplace; the employer violated this duty by hiring an employee he knew or should have known had a propensity to become violent; the employee was injured; and the injury could have been avoided if the employer had exercised care in the selection or retention of the unqualified employee. A unique aspect of current negligent hiring litigation is that it allows a third person to sue an employer who, through negligence, has placed an employee in a position such that he or she is afforded the opportunity to injure the plaintiff. No longer is negligent hiring solely an issue between a company and its workers; it is now a basis for recovery by the public against employers with faulty hiring practices. …
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Usry et al. (1991) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: