Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
North Carolina’s pilot program of court-ordered arbitration of civil cases involved an informal adversarial hearing in a courtroom before an arbitrator (an experienced attorney), held within sixty days of the last responsive pleading. The program was limited to suits for damages not exceeding $15,000 (most were based on a contract theory). Most cases that went to arbitration hearings ended in judgment on the arbitrator’s award. Trial de novo occurred in only nine percent of the cases that went to hearings. The program reduced the disposition time in eligible contested cases by one-third or more and cut the trial rate from 20 percent to seven percent. Evidently, arbitration hearings replaced out-of-court settlements more often than they replaced trials. Litigants assigned to the arbitration program were more satisfied with their experience than were litigants in a comparison group. These differences persisted in multivariate models that controlled for whether the litigant won, settled, or lost, and other factors associated with satisfaction. Attorneys were as satisfied with the program as with standard procedure, and strongly favored continuing the program.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Clarke et al. (1991) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: