Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Ratzinger's Republic:Pope Benedict XVI on Natural Law and Church and State Vincent L. Strand S.J. and Sam Zeno Conedera S.J. Given the place natural law holds in Catholic thought, it would be a serious charge to claim that a papal encyclical rejects natural law. According to Kevin M. Doak, that is what one of the present authors, Vincent Strand, has done in an article considering Pope Benedict XVI's Caritas in Veritate. 1 The aim of Strand's article was to demonstrate that the encyclical's method evinces a reliance on Henri de Lubac's theology of nature and grace, inasmuch as it derives economic policy from theological revelation. This is a consequence, it was suggested, of adopting the Lubacian view that human nature is intrinsically ordered to a supernatural end. In the course of the argument, Strand briefly noted that Caritas in Veritate has a meager reliance on natural law, which he suggested is not atypical for Benedict, who at times is skeptical about natural-law arguments because of his sense of reason being historically conditioned. 2 Professor Doak thinks this is a misreading of Benedict on natural law, one which stems from Strand's faulty analysis of nature and grace. 3 [End Page 669] Doak's criticism provides the opportunity to consider in finer relief Benedict's thinking on natural law, which, as Doak rightly points out, is an understudied area of the former Pope's theology, particularly in Anglophone scholarship. 4 Because Benedict's references to natural law are ensconced in the wider matrix of his political thought, we need to widen our vision to consider his political theory more broadly in order to understand his view of natural law. As we do so, an unresolved tension comes into view. On the one hand, Benedict's sense of reason being historically conditioned and in need of revelation leads him to argue that Christianity alone can provide the moral values the state requires; put simply, the state needs the Church. On the other hand, Benedict favors a non-confessional, pluralistic state; indeed, he believes it belongs to the very nature of the Church to be separate from the state. Faced with these two commitments, Benedict argues that the contribution the Church is to make to the state is to supply moral values that came about in the historical ambit of Christianity, but which can—and must—be stripped of their elements derived from divine revelation and reduced to their rational kernel, which in theory is accessible to all people, independent of their religious belief. Benedict's ambiguity about natural law is situated within this fundamental tension in his political theory: his notion of reason's historical embodiment and need of faith makes him suspicious of natural-law arguments, but his commitment to a liberal political arrangement leads him to employ natural law as an apparatus by which society can secure religiously neutral moral values. Benedict does not succeed in demonstrating the compatibility of the two poles that constitute the tension, which undermines the overall coherence of his political thought. Revisiting Nature and Grace and Natural Law Before turning to the question of natural law, however, we must first briefly respond to Doak's criticism of Strand's analysis of nature and grace, since Doak believes this is the origin of Strand's erroneous reading of Benedict on natural law. Doak gives no evidence that Strand's main point concerning nature and grace, namely, that Benedict's theology of nature and grace is influenced by the Lubacian theory, is flawed; in fact, Doak's praising Stephen Fields's reading of Benedict's theology of grace only supports Strand's primary claim, as Fields explicitly notes that he and Strand both find the influence of de Lubac on Benedict. 5 Moreover, it must be noted [End Page 670] that nowhere did Strand praise the Lubacian model of nature and grace or judge its effects on the method of Caritas in Veritate salutary. 6 Doak's central accusation is that Strand's portrayal of Thomism is "little more than a familiar stereotype." 7 The stereotype we suspect Doak has in mind is one that paints the...
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Strand et al. (2020) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: