Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
"Zealous in the Cause": Indian Violence, the Second Seminole War, and the Formation of a Southern Identity F. Evan Nooe (bio) In the nineteenth-century American South, to be white and a Southerner meant to harbor specific qualities and traits. Historians frequently focus on characteristics such as honor, hospitality, and good manners. Perhaps for nineteenth-century contemporaries, what a Southerner was not was equally important. They most certainly were not Northerners, cowards, or African Americans (free or slave). Highly overlooked but equally excluded by white Southerners were Native Americans. Today, historians of the Old South have possibly done just as much to neglect the role of Native Americans in creating a white Southern identity, primarily by focusing on North-South and white-black dichotomies. Those historians who have proposed a distinct Southern identity during the antebellum period primarily associate the region with slavery or nascent Confederate nationalism. 1 By illuminating the impact of Native Americans, specifically through violence and warfare, in shaping identity in the Old South we can better understand the creation and qualifications of a white, regionally based Southern identity. 2 Using violence and warfare as a historical lens, we can also see the implications of Southerners consolidating a regional identity for Native Americans inhabiting the same space. Possibly the most detrimental result for Southern Indians was the simplification of Native Americans in the region to a singular, uncivilized people in the white Southern mind. During the 1830s and 1840s, interactions between whites and the Seminoles of Florida were central to forming such conceptions of regional identity, cultural norms, and race. In understanding the construction of identity, it is important to consider two driving mechanisms. First, identity does not exist in isolation. [End Page 55] Groups often define who they are by emphasizing who they are not. In the case of white Southerners, there is, of course, the North, but a white Southern identity was also counterposed to groups such as Southern Native Americans and the United States federal government. White Southerners increasingly saw these two groups as frustrating and a hindrance to their goals. Second, we should consider how identity is a result of shared experience, common cultural norms, and a reactionary measure. For the South, sense of place adds an extra element to identity. John Harner's concept of "place identity" best explains the significance prescribed to a geographical location in identity formation. Harner defines place identity as a "cultural value shared by the community, a collective understanding about social identity intertwined with place meaning." Essentially, place takes on a temporal process in which "human experience and struggle" give a geographical location meaning. 3 In the antebellum South, the disputes between white Southerners and the Seminole Indians, distinct groups inhabiting the same space, characterized the human experiences and struggles that gave the region qualitative significance to both white Southerners and Seminoles. Previous historians have quarreled with the question of Southern distinctiveness, but most did not have the theoretical benefit of identity studies to guide their assessments. In 1957 William Taylor's Cavalier and Yankee examined the development of a romantic-styled Southerner. A mass of antebellum novelists, commentators, and politicians cultivated and enveloped themselves in an imagined region dominated by benevolent plantations that coincidentally justified the continuation of slavery. 4 Primarily focusing on political divisions, John Richard Alden's 1961 work The First South argued a Southern separateness was present from the founding of the nation. According to Alden, despite the formation of the Union, the Revolutionary Era saw the new nation aligned by regional interests regarding such matters as the location of the capital, the slave trade, and congressional representation. 5 More recent studies on the development of the South examine regional interests as opposed to the formation of a unifying identity. However, modern historians continue in the vein of John Hope Franklin's 1956 emphasis on the South as consumed with "Defending the Cornerstone." 6 Undeniably, slavery was an integral institution to the region. But if we take an increasingly narrow view of the region as solely defined by slavery and ignore other influences, we risk turning the South [End Page 56] into a caricature of a white-master black-slave script. Additionally, there...
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
F. Evan Nooe (2011) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 8 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: