Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Introduction Dr. Felson: The experts on this panel have been selected because of their deep interest and outstanding contributions in the field of chest roentgenology. They will present their points of view on certain fundamental problems which are encountered in the interpretation of chest roentgenograms. As to the technic of this exercise, we are going to do something different. This is not a film-reading session, a guessing game in which the cases are presented as unknowns to the panelists. Instead, I will present cases which illustrate one of the topics chosen for discussion. I will point out the salient roentgen features and give the diagnosis. Then I will ask specific questions related to the subject illustrated. The case material has been selected to bring out certain basic concepts and the questions I will ask, for the most part, will express my own uncertainties. Calcification In “Coin” Lesions Figure 1 is a laminagram of a large nodule containing an eccentric calcification. Subsequent roentgenograms showed a gradual diminution in its size, and by the end of two years the nodule had disappeared, leaving a small scar. The patient had received no treatment. Figure 2 shows a small nodule with central calcification in a 45-year-old white male who was asymptomatic. During the two-and-a-half-year interval between A and B the nodule more than doubled in size. It was resected and found to be a granuloma. Histoplasma capsulatum was demonstrated on direct smear. Figure 3 shows a primary carcinoma which engulfed a pre-existing pulmonary calcification. Dr. Rabin, if you had a “coin” lesion containing calcium in your own chest, would you have it resected? Dr. Rabin: That would depend on its roentgen appearance. If there were a large central calcification or a concentric calcified ring I would not be operated upon because there is no tendency for that type of lesion to spread. However, if there were a small central calcification with considerable noncalcified tissue about it and evidence of growth on subsequent films, I would have it resected because some of these lesions are actively inflammatory in nature. In the first case you showed (Fig. 1) I believe resection should have been performed initially, even though the lesion subsequently disappeared. I think it represented a blocked tuberculous cavity and the patient would have been better off without it. Dr. Felson: Have you personally seen a primary malignant lung nodule which contained calcium? Dr. Rabin: Yes. One should be certain, of course, that the calcium is within the nodule because, on a single film, calcium behind or in front of the lesion may appear to lie within it. A malignant tumor may engulf an earlier calcium deposit, as you have shown (Fig. 3). This can be suspected if one or more small calcific deposits are seen near the periphery of the nodule.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Felson et al. (1959) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: