Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
CONSIDERABLE literature is available pertaini ing to various methods of teaching reading. One of the major areas of controversy has been the area of phonics. Questions of when to teach phonics, and of what kind of phonics to teach are of prime impor tance. Gates and Russell (5) and T?te, Herbert, and Zeman (6) find that formal phonics dr ill tends to be less effective than natural or intrinsic type phonics. Agnew (1) suggests that while the number of errors made by children who learn byphonetic methods is smaller, these children tend to read more slowly than others. The common conclusion from such data is that children should learn to read by means of developing a sight vocabulary at the outset; they should later learn some intrinsic phon ics. While a six and a half years mental age is gen erally recognized (3) as the age at which most child ren are ready to read by aphonie method, Gates (4), indicated that this may beafunction of the teaching method. The present study represents an experimental test of this position.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Richard H. Bloomer (1960) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: