Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
What Happens to Our Wishes:Magical Thinking in Harry Potter Judith P. Robertson (bio) Since Harry Potter's appearance in 1997, critical response has not done justice to the young sorcerer's enormous appeal and the search for truth in childhood.1 Among notable exceptions are Natov, Tucker, and Zipes. Forms of response tend to converge around the story's staggering market success, censorship debates, and Joanne Kathleen Rowling's biography.2 Less common are analyses that rethink the dynamic relation of fantasy fiction to the passionate mental processes of childhood and children's uses of transitional objects—including word play, rhetorical figures, literary forms, and reading experience—to create their magical realities and to allay their anxieties. In this article, I assess the allure of Harry Potter by reconstructing its conditions of success within psychological experiences provoked by the deeper structures of the narrative. Of particular interest to me is what Hélène Cixous calls "the mystery of literary creation and the secret of this enviable power possessed by its creator who manages to seduce us" (527). What Cixous calls a "beckoning" (527) is for Paul de Man that irreducible "something often referred to as literariness" (8). In his attempt to account for the problematic nature of reading (i.e., why being seduced by a story is so difficult to explain), de Man lays stress on the destabilizing effects of language. He signals the "autonomous potential of language" to subvert or somehow overthrow the controlling structures of aesthetic form (10). I am interested in how Harry Potter functions in this way as a region of formal linguistic and literary play that propels child entry to some elemental problems of inner life. "All our stories," writes Adam Phillips, "are about what happens to our wishes. About the world as we would like it to be, and the world as it happens to be, irrespective of our wishes and despite our hopes. Our needs thwarted by the needs of others, our romances always threatened by tragedy, our jokes ruined by the people who don't get them. The usual antagonism of daydream and reality" (Beast xiii). Rowling utilizes aesthetic form as a holding device whose function is to keep to a manageable scale the disorienting uncanniness of wishes, while at the same time allowing mental space for the exercise of magical thinking to transgress those laws that give rise to the very developmental tasks of childhood. Fantasy and Inner Life in Childhood Childhood is situated at a thoroughfare of impossible demands: being dependent on others for survival; having no say in the matter of having to grow up to responsibility and independence; wanting (contemporaneously) care, love, interest, freedom, and power; and being properly suspicious of a world over which being young exercises little command. If children's inner realities are filled with passionate predicaments, it is the corresponding structures of feeling that fantasy acknowledges and contains. Rowling remembers the dissonant psychic realities of childhood inferiority: "I really can, with no difficulty at all, think myself back to eleven years old.... I can remember being a kid and being very powerless and having this whole underworld that to adults is always going to be impenetrable" (Shapiro 5). "I definitely wouldn't go back and do childhood again. I don't look back on it as a phase of blissful happiness at all" (de Bertodano 1156). About her famous character's struggle to learn amidst lessons that can be painfully difficult, the author says, "I suddenly had this basic idea of a boy who didn't know what he was" (Shapiro 49). "He had a powerful kind of ache inside him, half joy, half terrible sadness" (de Bertodano). In the tradition of the psychological realism of other celebrated fantasists, including her favorites—such as Graham Greene, Edith Nesbit, Jane Austen, C. S. Lewis, Colette, Nabokov, and Ian Fleming—Rowling engages readers at the very boundaries of language. She arouses the reader's ability to shift and play with parts of being that involve feeling anxious or vulnerable, and thereby making something possible in the work of self-symbolization.3 Moreover, the author's rainbow coalition of magical and non-magical creatures stages...
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Judith P. Robertson (2001) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: