Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The compatibility of the death penalty with the rule of law along with the support of almost half of the Ukrainians surveyed a year before the full-scale invasion of Ukraine by the Russian Federation, has highlighted the necessity for a deeper study of the nature of this form of punishment, its origins, and the trends surrounding its implementation and abolition. This article aims to review and analyse the reasons for the establishment, persistence, and abolition of the death penalty as a form of punishment in ancient Egypt, ancient Greece, and Rome, as well as in the Moscow State and later in the Russian Empire. The selection of these states is based on the availability of relevant research materials and the clarity with which their historical experiences illustrate the findings presented in the article. The study establishes that the primary understanding of execution as retribution originates from the principle of “an eye for an eye” or equal for equal (committed). This principle, now known as lex talionis (in all its forms), was then practically implemented based on the perceptions of justice and/or religious traditions.Furthermore, this study finds that over time, the death penalty evolved from means of vengeance, including blood feuds, into a tool for maintaining state stability and social order.In this context, the purpose of the death penalty shifts — from retribution to deterrence — while its public execution gains prominence as a visual and “educational” tool. The concept of justice is also changing.Justice is presumed inherent in any death sentence sanctioned by the state. State leaders hold the authority to determine which offenses warrant death penalty.An analysis of the history of death penalty in the Ancient East and Antiquity suggests that a person’s status as a slave did not preclude recognition of their execution by a court or other judicial body as the deliberate termination of a human being. However, due to the legal norms of the time, death penalty sometimes had a collective nature, leading to the execution of innocent individuals.This analysis suggests that when significant threats to society diminish, the perceived necessity for this form of punishment also declines. The presence of a substantial threat, or a combination of such threats, is typically the primary factor prompting the incorporation of the death penalty into a legal system. The findings of this study do not provide sufficient grounds to assert the absence of legal justification for either the establishment or retention of the death penalty. However, such considerations may fall beyond the scope of this study. Future research will be conducted based on the conclusions drawn here.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Zvieriev et al. (2025) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: