This is the authors' abstract. We don't add key points for this paper.
To the Editor: We recently read with excitement the Neurosurgical Focus volume titled Education Methodology and Metrics in the Training of Neurosurgical Residents.1 The Focus volume drew attention to a number of innovative educational initiatives including simulation, virtual reality, milestone evaluations, intraoperative autonomy assessments, and subintern curriculum reforms.2-6 Much of the neurosurgical education literature concentrates on systematic improvements, pilot studies, educational theory, or highlighting gaps in training.7-14 However, there is no centralized repository of tangible opportunities for those interested in becoming neurosurgical educators. Our letter aims to outline resources that residents and fellows as well as junior and senior faculty can join to improve their skills and practice as surgical educators. Neurosurgeons who share this interest will be offered a landscape of the current institutional and national certificate programs, medical education degrees, target journals, and medical education conferences. Certificate programs remain a common and practical means of obtaining a short-term, high-yield primer for medical education. Many institutions have outstanding local programs (Table). At a national level, Harvard Macy Institute remains a pillar for medical education training, offering 6 courses. Two of these are particularly important to highlight: for residents and fellows, the Program for Post-Graduate Trainees: Future Academic Clinician-Educators (PGME) is a 3-day (currently virtual) foundational course in medical education; for faculty, the Program for Educators in Health Professions runs over the course of a year and includes Fall and Spring 3-day sessions intermixed with monthly continuity sessions (harvardmacy.org). For surgical faculty members, the American College of Surgeons offers “Surgeons as Educators,” a 6-day immersive and intensive course covering teaching skills, curriculum development, and program evaluation geared for individuals with an educational leadership role. TABLE. - Medical Education Resources: Target Journals, Certificates, and Master's Programs Target journal (impact factor) Institutional certificate programs Master’s programs Medical Education Journals Surgical Education and Training Duke Academy Health Professions, Education, and Academic Development (AHEAD) Masters in Academic Medicine at USC Keck Academic Medicine (8.034) JAMA Surgery (16.68) Duke Medical Education Leadership Track (MELT) Master of Health Professions Education at University of Illinois Chicago Medical Education (6.25) Journal of Surgical Education (2.891) Education Leadership Certificate as UCSF Medical Education Master’s at the University of Pennsylvania Advances in Health Sciences Education (3.85) American Journal of Surgery/Association for Surgical Education (2.403) University of Texas Physician Educator Certificate Program Master’s in Medical Sciences and Medical Education at Harvard Medical Teacher (3.65) Global Surgical Education Medical Educator Certificate Program at Northwestern Medical Education Online (3.298) University of Utah Healthcare Academy of Health Science and Educators Teaching and Learning in Medicine (2.414) Simulation in Healthcare (2.160) Journal of Continuing Education in the Health Professions (1.355) Journal of Graduate Medical Education (1.23) MedEdPortal (0.96) Clinical Teacher (0.763) Medical Science Educator (0.760) Physicians desiring a more formal and longitudinal educational training may pursue a master's degree. The most robust master's degree programs in medical education are listed in Table. These are generally 2-year programs geared toward physicians with a specific interest in medical education research and include a capstone project. Published scholarship in medical education and training appears in several medical education-specific journals (with impact factor listed in Table). Many of these journals also host educational forums held by their host society, for example USC Innovations in Medical Education Conference and Association for Surgical Education Conference. Although many neurosurgical journals dedicate sections to specific subspecialty areas of practice, there is no such designation for neurosurgical education. Although JNS Focus did recently devote the August 2022 issue to Education, an exciting opportunity remains for a neurosurgery-specific journal to create a regular subsection dedicated to neurosurgical education. Venues are also emerging for the presentation of original educational scholarship at US neurosurgical meetings. The Congress of Neurological Surgeons Annual Meeting in 2022 held its first abstract session dedicated to Medical Education and Training and signals an ongoing commitment to fostering and supporting medical education, cosponsored by the Society of Neurological Surgeons (SNS), which represents US neurosurgery residency directors and academic department chairs. The SNS has created a Neurosurgical Educator Development Program to identify and help fund neurosurgical junior faculty members undertaking specific longitudinal training in surgical education methods and scholarship. The Neurosurgical Educator Development Program will be announced at the 2023 SNS Annual Meeting in Dallas, Texas. A majority of US medical schools offer faculty promotion pathways for clinician educators.15,16 In general, such pathways value objective evidence of excellence in education, including high marks in objective teaching evaluations, teaching awards, the creation of durable educational materials, peer-reviewed educational science, external funding for educational programs and projects, specific mentorship of future clinician educators, service on institutional or national educational committees, educational society board leadership, and formal major teaching roles (such as medical school course or clerkship director, residency program director, or ACGME-designated institutional official). These accomplishments also allow candidates for promotion to demonstrate the requisite regional or national reputation as an educational leader. Academic neurosurgical departments share 3 core missions: patient care, research, and education. Vast resources currently exist to train neurosurgeons to provide excellent patient care and execute high-quality research. Resources for training faculty in effective teaching and educational scholarship are much more limited. Recently, residency duty-hour limit restrictions on operative time, public concerns about trainee supervision, decreasing trainee autonomy, and data regarding resident competence at the conclusion of training have increased interest in surgical education techniques and outcomes.17-23 In response, US neurosurgery has begun to make significant strides in developing more robust educational infrastructure for residency and subspecialty fellowship training, including a consensus national curriculum, standardized neurosurgical training, milestones, case minimums, systematic national courses; fellowship accreditation; expanding professional development for educators; promoting training in research; and coordinating policy.7 Training and promoting neurosurgical educators should become a core feature of the specialty of neurosurgery. Neurosurgical departments and organizations should invest in and support educational initiatives at individual and system levels to improve medical student, residency, and fellowship training and lifelong learning during practice, ultimately in the service of patient outcomes and safety. By consolidating this list of current, existing resources, we hope that trainees and faculty may find it easier to capitalize on these opportunities to further their interest and expertise as neurosurgical educators.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Suarez et al. (2023) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: