Key result
Believing they were breathing 15% O2 significantly increased dyspnea by 0.70 units compared to room air (p=0.03) and by 1.05 units compared to 23% O2 (p=0.003), without physiological changes.
Why the study?
It was unknown how dyspnea or leg discomfort during exercise can be influenced by expectations.
Does expectation of breathing hypoxic or hyperoxic gas influence perceived dyspnea and leg discomfort during submaximal cycling in healthy participants?
Does expectation of breathing hypoxic or hyperoxic gas influence perceived dyspnea and leg discomfort during submaximal cycling in healthy participants?
Mean Difference: 0.7
p-value: p=0.03
Dyspnea during exercise is susceptible to expectancy without accompanying physiological changes, highlighting the need to consider psychological factors when evaluating breathlessness.
Expectancy may inflate dyspnea ratings in exercise testing; hypothesis-generating for psychological factors in breathlessness assessment.
Rating of perceived exertion (RPE) is used to subjectively quantify the perception of physical activity, breathlessness or dyspnea, and leg discomfort (RPE legs ) during exercise. However, it is unknown how dyspnea or RPE legs can be influenced by expectations. Thirty healthy, active participants (19 males, 11 females) completed five, 5-minute submaximal cycling trials at 60% peak work rate. We deceived participants by telling them they were inspiring different hypoxic and hyperoxic gases, when in fact they breathed room air. Cardiorespiratory variables were similar between the trials, however, dyspnea and RPE legs evaluated with a Borg scale changed in a dose–response manner. When participants believed they were breathing 15% O 2 , they significantly increased dyspnea +0.70 ± 0.2 units ( p = 0.03) compared to room air, whereas RPE legs was unchanged +0.35 ± 0.1 units ( p = 0.70). When participants believed they were breathing 15% O 2 , they significantly increased dyspnea +1.05 ± 0.4 units ( p = 0.003) compared to 23% hyperoxic condition, whereas RPE legs was unchanged +0.35 ± 0.1 units ( p = 0.70). We found that dyspnea during exercise is susceptible to expectancy, without any accompanying physiological changes. Given coaches and clinicians use perceived exertion to prescribe exercise intensity and evaluate treatments, our findings show that the effect of expectations must be considered when interpreting sensations of breathlessness.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Kipp et al. (2022) studied Healthy, active participants (n=30). Deception of inspiring hypoxic gas (15% O2) vs. Room air was evaluated on Dyspnea evaluated with a Borg scale (MD 0.70, p=0.03). Believing they were breathing 15% O2 significantly increased dyspnea by 0.70 units compared to room air (p=0.03) and by 1.05 units compared to 23% O2 (p=0.003), without physiological changes.
Synapse has enriched 5 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: