Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The article seeks to answer two questions on the basis of over two hundred scholarly studies published in the yearbooks of the Izraelita Magyar Irodalmi Társulat (Israelite Hungarian Literary Society, or IMIT) that were released between 1929 and 1943. First, what notions of historicity did Hungarian Jewish scholars articulate in the 1930s and early 1940s, during the time between assimilationism and catastrophe? Second, how was the modern idea of history negotiated in their writings and how did other key concepts (such as religion, redemption or character) accompany its discussion? In other words, the article reconstructs the implicit Jewish scholarly debate concerning the historicity of Jews. The perspectives presented and analysed range from studying historical evidence in order to claim a special Jewish pedigree on a rationalist basis (Lajos Venetianer) and denigrating the importance of existing empirical evidence on a teleological basis (József Turóczi-Trostler) all the way to denying the relevance of historical changes altogether for the sake of ahistorical essentialism (István Hahn). The article shows that other contributors to the IMIT Yearbooks positioned themselves between these two ends of the spectrum: they sought utopian ways out of history (Mór Fényes) or could combine utopian notions with directly political agendas (Zsigmond Groszmann, Ervin György Patai). Still others stressed the insignificance of history as opposed to the unity of tradition (Pál Hirschler, Bernát Heller) or communicated the vision of its basic injustice and opposed it to the qualities of the Jewish character (Mátyás Rubinstein, Bertalan Edelstein, Bertalan Kohlbach).
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Ferenc Laczó (2011) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: