Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This case comment considers the 9 September 2021 Decision on Jurisdiction, Liability and Directions of Quantum in Eco Oro v Colombia (Decision), an ICSID arbitration arising under the ‘new-generation’ Canada–Colombia Free Trade Agreement (FTA).3 The divided Tribunal held (by a majority) that the respondent State’s decision to prohibit mining activities in environmentally sensitive wetlands did not amount to an unlawful expropriation by operation of the police powers doctrine, informed by the treaty’s expropriation annex.4 However, a different majority of the Tribunal went on to hold that the delays and inconsistent treatment of the investor by different parts of the Colombian State in connection with protecting and delimiting the wetlands violated the minimum standard of treatment (MST) under international law.5 In so doing, the majority effectively shortcut the environmental exception in the FTA, considering whether the environmental exception operated as a defence on the merits, but only with respect to whether to exclude the requirement to pay compensation, once liability had been established. The majority inferred the treaty parties’ intention that the exception would not generally operate to exclude the respondent State’s duty to pay compensation, notwithstanding express statements by the treaty parties, including in Canada’s non-disputing treaty party submission, to the contrary.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Robert Garden (2022) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: