Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Bilateral striatal necrosis is a pathologic diagnosis that can be subdivided clinically into three subgroups: (1) metabolic, such as subacute necrotizing encephalomyelopathy (Leigh's disease); (2) familial degeneration of the striatum; and (3) acute disease in the parainfectious or postinfectious setting.1 The clinicoradiographic definition of this last subgroup can be attributed to Goutieres and Aicardi1 who first called attention to it in 1982. The pathogenesis of the syndrome is not known but its occurrence in the context of a recent infectious illness suggests a restricted encephalitis of the striatum or a postinfectious immune-mediated process. We report the case of a 7-year-old girl who had this syndrome associated with Mycoplasma pneumoniae infection. Case report. The patient was a 7-year-old girl who was moderately mentally retarded with no neurologic deficits before onset of her illness. There was a 2-week history of an upper respiratory tract illness with coughing. During a 2-day period she became less verbal with diminished facial expression and drooling. Her movements were slow and tremulous. At times she would appear agitated and cry out that she hurt, but she did not localize any pain. The past medical history was significant for moderate mental retardation, hyperactivity and aggressive behavior. She had been evaluated for this 9 months before the present illness with metabolic screening tests and a head computerized tomography scan which were normal. On admission she was alert but mute, afebrile and diaphoretic. She had striking Parkinsonian features including a coarse resting tremor, bradykinesia, rigidity, mask facies and a slow shuffling gait. This presentation suggested possible phenothiazine ingestion but there was no history of drug ingestion, the toxicology screening test was negative and there was no change when diphenhydramine was given intravenously. During the next 1 to 2 days she became progressively more dystonic and akinetic and held the extremities in flexion. She was unable to eat or swallow and her only vocalization was a monotonous wailing cry. Multiple medications including diazepam, artane, carbidopa-levodopa, baclofen and dantrolene were tried without benefit. After 2 weeks she developed some facial expression and left sided movement followed 1 week later by right sided movement. At 6 weeks her recovery was almost complete with only mild right-sided dystonia and weakness. After 2 years the patient has not had further episodes and her parents report that she has returned to her baseline motor and mental status. At the time of presentation a head computerized tomography scan showed bilateral hypodensity of the striatum. Four days later a magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) scan showed increased signal on T2 images in the same area (Fig. 1). Marked volume loss of the striatum consistent with striatal necrosis was seen at 6 weeks on a follow-up MRI scan (Fig. 2). Other studies on presentation included a chest radiograph which showed a left lower lobe infiltrate. Cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) examination showed the following: glucose, 73 mg/dl; protein, 23 mg/dl; white blood cells, 4/mm3; negative culture. CSF studies repeated 1 week later showed no change. Serum and urine manganese values were initially reported as elevated but repeated studies were normal. Negative laboratory studies included: complete blood count; urinalysis; toxicology screening test; lactate; ammonia; liver function tests; urine organic acids and amino acids; antinuclear antibody; serum copper; serum zinc; serum immunoglobulins; viral and bacterial cultures; and antibody titers to Epstein-Barr virus and herpes simplex virus. With an immunofluorescent antibody technique, serum IgM and IgG M. pneumoniae antibody titers run simultaneously from admission, 1 week, 6 weeks and 3 months, respectively, were: IgM, 1:320, 1:80, 1:40 and 1:20; and IgG, 1:256, 1:256, 1:64 and 1:64. CSF immunofluorescence assay IgM and IgG titers to M. pneumoniae on admission and at 1 week were negative. Discussion. Bilateral striatal necrosis in infants and children can have a variety of clinical presentations and etiologies.2, 3 Various systems of classification have been proposed but are hampered by a lack of definitive diagnosis in many cases. There has emerged in recent years the recognition of the clinical radiographic syndrome of acute striatal necrosis with characteristic extrapyramidal symptoms and remarkable recovery despite persistent radiographic evidence of striatal necrosis.1, 4, 5 This syndrome typically occurs in an infectious or postinfectious setting. The clinical presentation is characterized by some degree of alteration of consciousness associated with prominent extrapyramidal findings. Bradykinesia, tremor, rigidity and mutism are typical. The patients often require tube feedings because of the lack of swallowing but usually do not require respiratory support. The behavioral response to most stimuli is an unusual high pitched monotonous wailing cry. In days to weeks there is recovery with minimal if any neurologic sequelae. Infectious agents reported to be associated with this syndrome include mumps and Echo 25 viruses.1, 6M. pneumoniae should be added to this list. In addition to our patient there have been three case reports of patients with acute striatal lesions that may have been associated with M. pneumoniae infection.7-9 The first case was reported by Al-Mateen et al.7 this 9-year-old girl had akinetic rigidity and dyskinesia with bilateral basal ganglia lesions. The M. pneumoniae antibody titer rose from 1:512 to 1:2048 (CSF titers were not reported). Although the motor deficits resolved she had persistent cognitive deficits. The second reported case clinically fit the syndrome and had positive cold agglutinins and a M. pneumoniae titer of 1:32.8 Unfortunately they did not have serial titers, which would have provided more definite evidence for a recent infection. The atypical features of this case were the development of persistent chorea 1 year after his initial symptoms had resolved and the MRI showing at that time lesions not only in the putamen but also in the basis pontis. The third case was initially reported as one of six patients who had CSF evidence by PCR of central nervous system (CNS) M. pneumoniae infection and then as an individual case report.9, 10 This 11-year-old boy presented with aseptic meningitis and a seizure. He then developed bradykinesia, loss of facial expression, blepharoptosis, dysarthria and dysphagia. The MRI scan showed bilateral high intensity striatal lesions on T2 images. Acute serum antibody titers were 1:2560 and convalescent titers were 1:640. CSF antibody titers were negative but CSF PCR for M. pneumoniae was positive, supporting invasion of the CNS by the organism. Carbidopa-levodopa (200/20 mg per day) was used and the authors believed that the patient had some benefit from the drug. They recommended a trial of L-dopa in these patients. (We gave our patient carbidopa-levodopa up to 1000/100 mg per day and found no benefit.) By the seventh week the patient had recovered almost completely except for a few choreic movements. Our patient's clinical course and radiographic findings were typical for the syndrome of acute striatal necrosis. The antibody titers to M. pneumoniae showed a 16-fold change in serum IgM titers and a 4-fold change to IgG titers supporting a temporal relationship of her neurologic disease with M. pneumoniae infection. The exact role of Mycoplasma in causing the striatal necrosis is unknown. Possible pathologic mechanisms include direct CNS invasion, an autoimmune process or a neurotoxic effect.11 Although our patient had negative CSF antibody titers so did the patient of Saitoh et al., and yet by PCR technique M. pneumoniae DNA was detected in the CSF of the patient, raising the possibility that direct CNS invasion by the organism may be important in causing the condition.9 Why the striatum would be selectively vulnerable to the infectious insult is also unclear. One possibility is that there may be an underlying metabolic vulnerability of the basal ganglia that the acute infection unmasks. Although our patient's clinical course, metabolic evaluation and premorbid computerized tomography scan did not suggest an underlying metabolic abnormality, her moderate mental retardation remains unexplained, raising the possibility that an unidentified metabolic condition may have predisposed her to the striatal necrosis when she had the acute infection. Metabolic causes of basal ganglia lesions12-16 should be screened for in these patients as well as considering infectious agents. In a recent review of CNS complications of M. pneumoniae infection, meningoencephalitis, meningitis, encephalitis, polyradiculitis, acute cerebellar ataxia, cranial nerve neuropathy, and transverse myelitis were listed.11 We recommend that the extrapyramidal syndrome of acute bilateral striatal necrosis should be added to this list. Paul D. Larsen, M.D.; Darrell Crisp, M.D.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Larsen et al. (1996) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: