Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
In late 1995 a survey was conducted at the Melbourne, Australia, branch of the Ludwig Institute for Cancer Research (LICR), to determine the information needs and the information seeking behaviour of the research staff. LICR is an international organization dedicated to basic and clinical research. The Melbourne branch has approximately 120 staff: 40 of whom are technical staff, and approximately 15 are doctoral students; the remainder, apart from a small number of administrative staff, are clinical oncologists and research scientists. LICR is located in what is known locally as the ‘Parkville strip’, which is an area adjacent to the University of Melbourne with a high density of teaching hospitals and research institutes. The LICR maintains a ‘one person’ library, which provides the normal range of services expected from a small specialist library. Lack of space is a problem, hence many journals are stored in microfiche format. A range of CD-ROM databases are available in the library and over the local area network, and are supplemented by online searching as required. A brief literature review was conducted of the information seeking behaviour of medical researchers. This indicated that there was heavy reliance on journals for both current and retrospective information, a high incidence of end-user online searching in some age groups, but the most up-to-date information was often discovered through meetings and personal contacts rather than publications. 1 Timely location of required information was a requisite of medical research, 2 although researchers also tended to rely on personal reference collections. Willingness to use electronic information sources seemed to be age dependent. 3 These three sources and several others showed that Medline was the major bibliographical tool accessed by those involved in medical research. The only previous research located that dealt specifically with the information needs of medical oncologists was a Masters thesis. 4 This reported that problems were lack of time for information-seeking, and the proliferation of journals in the cancer field, which made it impossible to keep up-to-date. Exploratory interviews were conducted with four LICR staff members who represented a cross-section of scientists, researchers and research students. Material gathered from these interviews was used to design a self-administered questionnaire to be distributed to all LICR research staff. After a pilot study, the questionnaire was distributed to 64 LICR staff, and a response was received from 66% (n = 42). The results were analysed using the Statistical Package for the Social Sciences (SPSS). The exploratory interviews revealed that all four staff members consistently used other libraries to supplement what was available from the LICR library. This was due to the LICR’s unique position, in close vicinity to the Medical Library of the University of Melbourne and other medical and scientific library collections. Moreover, some staff would have trained or worked at some of these neighbouring institutions and would be familiar with their libraries. People featured highly as informal information sources, mainly through interaction with LICR colleagues or the wider scientific network through e-mail, conferences and refereeing unpublished papers. All inter-viewees needed to search for information daily and all preferred electronic formats for searching. However, once the information source had been identified, a hard copy format was preferred. This was particularly important for scientific journals with high-quality tables, diagrams or photographs. Thus electronic versions of these journals were not favoured; however, it should be noted that graphic representation in electronic journals has improved since the time of the research. Although all interviewees could do their own searching, all felt that assistance from library staff either in performing searches or in coaching for better searching techniques was desirable. They used a range of information sources, depending on their area of research, but all cited one or two key journals. Pressure of clinical work for the oncologists limited the time that could be spent on information-seeking. The questionnaire reflected the issues identified in the interviews, which warranted further investigation. It was designed to take only 15 min to complete, in deference to the workload of LICR staff. Questions were included about the most frequently used information sources, location tools, indexing tools, and use of other libraries. One question asked respondents to rate their satisfaction with their skills in searching the four sources most frequently mentioned in the exploratory interviews: Medline, Current Contents, Reference Update and the Internet. The most frequently used information source was colleagues, with 71% of respondents consulting colleagues on a daily basis. The next highest was journal articles in print format, with 40% of respondents using this source daily and a further 86% using it more than once a week. The Internet was used by 31% daily and by 55% more than once a week. Only 2.4% used electronic journals daily, but 26% of the respondents used them weekly. Only five of the 42 respondents were over 40 years of age (four respondents chose not to answer the question about age), but of these, only one made daily use of the Internet, one other accessed it weekly, and the remaining three used it fortnightly or less. The most popular method of locating information sources was to browse the contents pages of journals; for 79% of respondents this was an activity that took place at least once a week. The Internet was used as a location tool by 33% at least once a week, and the same percentage used abstracting or indexing services at least once a week. Medline on CD-ROM was the only indexing tool used on a daily basis, used by 4.9% of the respondents. It was used more than once a week by 41% of the respondents. The next most highly used indexing tool was Reference Update, with 12% of the respondents using it more than once a week. Current Contents was used at least weekly by 9% of the respondents, and at least once a fortnight by 21%. Personal collections held by respondents were accessed by 64% on a daily basis, and by 21% on a weekly basis. The LICR library was used by all respondents, daily by 45% and once a week or more by 93%. There was considerable use of libraries in neighbouring institutions. In response to the question about satisfaction rates in searching online and cd-rom products, there was highest satisfaction with end-user searching of Medline—65% of the respondents were satisfied or completely satisfied with their search technique. The results for Current Contents and Reference Update were not so positive. The satisfied/completely satisfied percentage for these were 38% and 33%, respectively. With Internet use, there was a correlation between frequency of use and satisfaction with searching skills: 46% of the respondents were satisfied and used it weekly or more; 32% of the respondents were unsure or not satisfied with their use of the Internet and used it monthly or less. The results of this survey demonstrate that LICR staff had similar information needs to other medical researchers. Colleagues were an important information source for daily work-related queries, whilst journal articles in print format provided the major published information source. The preferred methods of locating information were through Medline and browsing the contents pages of journals. The comparatively low use of databases other than Medline conforms with the information-seeking behaviour of medical researchers generally, as revealed in the literature review. LICR staff make high use of electronic information products, although searching skills in this area varied widely. There was some confusion about different software and the implications of searching online as compared to CD-ROM. The results for Internet searching may indicate that greater frequency of use leads to more efficient searching through practice and experience. It was clear from qualitative comments made on the questionnaires and in the exploratory interviews, that time for information-seeking was limited, especially for those staff involved in clinical work. The bias of the sample to younger age groups prevents generalization about age in relation to the use of electronic information sources, but the five respondents who were over 40 years of age did use the Internet and other electronic tools to a lesser degree. There was high use of the LICR library supplemented by use of neighbouring libraries, mainly for journal articles not available in the LICR library. However, some of the staff consulted in the exploratory interviews and pilot questionnaire did explain that sometimes they would go to another library to view a journal that was held in LICR library, but in microfiche format. They found the microfiche cumbersome to use and sometimes illegible. This could suggest that, as in the literature, this group of medical researchers place high emphasis on ease of use or ready access to information. All the respondents did use nearby libraries regularly, but frequency of use varied greatly. Apart from this particular result, which was directly related to the LICR’s location, this study confirmed the findings of earlier research into the information-seeking behaviour of medical researchers, as reported in the literature.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Murray et al. (1999) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: