Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The effect of substrate type and potential refuge on the vulnerability of four stream-living insect prey to two insect predators was studied by comparing predator capture success on each substrate in laboratory stream chambers. Prey were two Ephemeroptera, Baetis tricaudatus (Baetidae) and Ephemerella subvaria (Ephemerellidae), Simulium vittatum (Diptera:Simuliidae), and several species of Hydropsychidae (Trichoptera). Single prey taxa or mixed prey species were exposed to the predators Agnetina capitata (Plecoptera:Perlidae) and Nigronia serricornis (Megaloptera:Corydalidae). Substrate treatments were: very coarse sand, gravel-pebble, artificial turf, and, when testing for the protectiveness of hydropsychid retreats, gravel with additional sand. In single and mixed-prey experiments, mayflies, especially Baetis, were more vulnerable than other prey. When given no choice of prey, both predators captured prey on all substrates. Substrate significantly affected the vulnerability of three taxa, but in different ways for different predators. Turf allowed the capture of more Baetis by Nigronia, but fewer Baetis and Ephemerella by Agnetina. On gravel, hydropsychids were vulnerable to Agnetina; additional sand, however, allowed the construction of more or stronger retreats, reducing vulnerability. The same protection resulted from a 24-hr retreat-building period before exposure to Agnetina. With a choice of prey, Nigronia captured Baetis on all substrates, Ephemerella and Simulium on turf and gravel, and hydropsychids only on gravel. Agnetina with mixed prey took significantly more Baetis on all substrates but did not catch Ephemerella on turf. The swimming of Baetis probably contributed to its high vulnerability; the crawler (Ephemerella) and clingers (Simuliium, hydropsychids) were less conspicuous, or, in the case of Simulium, out of reach on the walls or ceilings of the chambers. The two predators also differed in their ability to forage on turf and sand. Agnetina was less successful in catching prey on turf whereas Nigronia had no difficulty. On sand, however, Agnetina was just as effective as on gravel whereas Nigronia captured only swimming prey on sand when a choice was available. These contrasting results are attributed to differences in the predators' antennae and agility. Therefore, substrate influences vulnerability not only by providing direct shelter but also by affecting the ease with which a predator can sense or pursue prey on particular substrates.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Fuller et al. (1990) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: