Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The construction of Christian identity is an ongoing and communicative process, the study of which requires not just ‘taking talk seriously’, but constitutively. As Christian disaffiliation becomes more common in the United States and forms of Christianity are implicated in violent white nationalism, what it means to be a Christian is being openly contested through language about church. The qualitative research in this study draws on 45 semi-structured interviews with Christian disaffiliates to uncover the discursive assertions they make about what it means to be Christian. A turning-point analysis reveals two commonly narrativized experiences altering these disaffiliates’ relationship with church: (1) culture shock, in which disaffiliates encountered new moral frameworks outside the social world of their childhood church and (2) embodied non-normativity, physically maturing into a person whose body does not fit heteropatriarchal church norms. Participants framed these two turning points in ways that discursively assert that Christians create hierarchies of who can be honest at church, premised on patriarchalism and heteronormativity. By taking disaffiliates’ narratives as partially constitutive of Christian identity, this study shows how people outside Christianity are shaping what it means to be a Christian in the United States today.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Elaine Schnabel (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: