This is the authors' abstract. We don't add key points for this paper.
Editors: Michel Y. Dubois, MD Rollin M. Gallagher, MD, MPH Philipp M. Lippe, MD With the collaboration of Michael Anello Reviewers: Frederick W. Burgess, MD, PhD Timothy R. Deer, MD Perry G. Fine, MD Scott M. Fishman, MD Kenneth A. Follett, MD, PhD Martin Grabois, MD Benson S. Munger, PhD Albert L. Ray, MD Lynn Webster, MD Since the 1950s, significant advances in the treatment of pain have resulted in greater relief for an increasing number of patients. However, the quality of pain care delivery in the United States continues to fall remarkably short of the current potential for optimal care. Pain medicine remains fragmented, and the absence of a unified organizational model of pain medicine hinders the effective provision of an integrated, cost-effective pain care, causing unnecessary and avoidable human suffering and societal expense. These consequences of fragmented care are unacceptable and threaten patient safety and well-being. Effective treatment of persistent pain requires the highest level of clinical reasoning, selectively coordinated medical skills, the strategic use of resources, and the orchestration of diverse areas of medical expertise. In order to close the gap between existing care and the potential for optimal pain care, significant institutional barriers to this goal must be addressed. To this end, the following position paper describes the history and context of this challenge, proposes recommendations to harness the collective abilities and knowledge within the discipline of pain medicine, and calls upon organized medicine to take action on behalf of patients and for the public health. Each year, $100 billion is spent on pain care, yet 40% of Americans experience daily pain, including 50 million people with chronic pain and 25 million people with acute pain. The prevalence of pain has a tremendous impact on business, with an estimated annual cost of $60 billion plus in lost productivity. Despite advances in the treatment of pain, the quality of pain care remains far below the potential for optimal care, and ineffective pain treatment continues to be a growing problem in the United States. The historic progress of pain care in the United States has encountered contemporary barriers that stand in the way of common sense change, and thus, pain medicine is fragmented, unable to provide integrated, comprehensive, and longitudinally cost-effective treatment. Fragmentation threatens patient safety because of inadequacies in 1) training programs, 2) number of qualified physicians, 3) federal funding of research, and 4) reimbursement policies. Closing the gap between the existing state of care and the potential for optimal pain care requires the removal of significant institutional barriers. Recommendations to achieve this include recognizing pain medicine as a primary specialty by the American Board of Medical Specialties (ABMS), creating a comprehensive residency training process accredited by the Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education (ACGME), and integrating diverse medical specialties to focus and improve research, diagnosis, and treatment of pain. Despite meager funding for pain research in the United States, the field of pain medicine is highly active, as demonstrated by growth in the number of pain medicine publications and journals, development of pain medicine associations, passage of pain medicine legislation for the military and Veterans Affairs, and most recently, congressional activity to pass the National Pain Care Policy Act of 2009. Significant advances are also evident in pain research, diagnosis, and therapy, including new techniques such as neurophysiologic testing, central and and the and of pain. current research, diagnosis, and treatment in pain medicine are by and barriers. the on the of pain medicine are of the potential for an optimal of pain care However, in the of pain medicine the United States such as and have pain medicine as a medical and the and are also such a in the of patients and the public is to in the of an optimal pain treatment. goal be the of pain medicine as an primary medical the development of residency in pain medicine, and for comprehensive, pain care of Pain Care in in the of Pain to in Pain of Pain as and to Pain and of of Pain Pain of Pain and in and in in Pain and of Pain Pain and in to for Effective Pain of Pain to American to of Care of Pain to Pain to Pain Policy and Recommendations Pain a for Pain of Pain Care Significant in the have resulted in greater relief pain for an increasing number of patients. However, the quality of treatment for pain in the United States remains unacceptable for of patients with acute persistent pain. the potential for a of optimal care within the discipline of pain medicine is contemporary pain care has the that be a comprehensive and to research, diagnosis, and treatment of pain. medicine has with and pain, a between and pain. of pain, as a to is medical as in such pain is short and persistent and the process is chronic the of pain is as in the pain by in of the in such as for for to have with the of daily because of and pain, also and pain that to the and with pain relief to most and to chronic and significant and pain medicine care to pain and quality of to have an delivery for the of an and with this to be the to a pain for treatment and for and and and the of between is to have a have that treatment to pain in this of patients have pain, have pain are persistent and in the pain are a the to pain that are to treatment. has to as in The of is medicine has to and In the of the as a of pain. The discipline of pain medicine is with the diagnosis, and of have pain and a such as pain pain with a be a in pain the primary such as pain pain is a the experience of pain is for most patients. is the patients experience pain as a of an as a chronic The of a patient with by of this experience a of that pain, pain, and pain. The experience of pain a of and of of be in of current to pain and treatment. inadequacies are for pain care. to 1) and and pain medicine for the of pain, for for the medical care of pain, and for medical 2) medical specialties for comprehensive 3) the to increasing patient for 4) and the treatment for the growing of patients with for the and and the knowledge of pain Each of inadequacies a significant to patient quality of and in the discipline of pain medicine have that the development of pain medicine to the of patients. In have with the of pain care the and the American Board of Pain have the of the to pain care The of the describes a comprehensive to with existing in the of the discipline of pain the of pain medicine has a of knowledge and of have and pain medicine is as a discipline by the American Medical The is of a of with a in pain and a common a of specialty including medicine, and the of has in the of a in the of pain medicine in the United States, the on 1) pain medicine with the most on the of pain medicine, 2) for pain medicine physicians, and 3) increasing the and of the specialty of pain The of the American of Pain is to the specialty of pain medicine and the comprehensive care of patients with pain of the clinical research, and medical in by the in this paper to of Pain pain medicine is a discipline that on of pain and pain as a this position the and recommendations to close the gap between potential for optimal pain care and a that for the effective delivery of pain These recommendations include the pain medicine as a primary medical specialty by the American Board of Medical Specialties a comprehensive Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education residency training process for pain medicine a comprehensive of pain care delivery that by integrating diverse medical specialties in the research, diagnosis, and treatment of pain. Pain has an of the human the of knowledge of pain has a history of by and research and pain, to the and for pain as a of that must be also as a to and to of pain in pain in a contemporary context in the in with advances in of in the for a in the development of to a that be pain and for of the of the in the medicine to be by by and techniques and and pain. In the of acute pain to be and to be by and care The of chronic pain on and as to the central and such as the use of as the primary to treatment. the the a that for the to a of to on the The for the and of the The to the to of patients. the the with to the patient with the in the to medical for use in pain the for an pain care is to the United States has that a of of and experience significant chronic pain following military the has on a of to an for the that a that is and the development of the techniques to the to and to to and that the with of and and in pain this medical advances in pain as significant as on pain, pain by a persistent pain for the most with the of persistent pain following to a by in of the American new of medicine in the in medical in the United States, by to in in the in the and of pain the to that the the for pain and to pain and suffering by techniques to the pain on techniques because to the of in the to chronic pain and and the in the the development and of pain a a a Specialties such as and also a in pain pain to be by a of specialties this training in pain, and with and care the growing development of care, with pain care, the to the and to the of the of pain as the suffering that of a and a to and pain as a in of new in the and on to a in the treatment of pain. has a for advances in pain medicine in the of that the experience for a patient and for the and a to in the in to in with the of The of a by MD, a and to by the of the a significant impact on pain and to the of pain medicine as a medical resulted as a to a and a pain that pain with also the of a fragmented, and and the of a to pain. The of the Pain by and in in this with the of the of and an model of pain, the and of pain. for the the of a of and of pain that to an in the of and the of chronic pain and 25 an of the for persistent pain to such as to the that persistent pain in a and a the of the the new medical discipline of pain medicine as the of in clinical and public the of has new for the that acute and persistent pain. is to of the pain experience are in the the impact of pain and on and the impact of to the with to pain the The is to be to the that with the of pain. The of also with clinical pain and pain To and pain and that a within the of the that pain in the to the are by and by that are by and the The and of a is as a pain to the In the contemporary pain medicine has the of pain the current of the of proposes that pain is a experience by of by a the also be of The is and by and is the primary that the that pain. is by of the is a that on the pain by have by and are In chronic pain that are by pain with in the central that are to and chronic is with persistent pain, the between and persistent pain remains The of Pain a new to In in to the of the Pain Care a of Pain and on Despite significant advances have in areas of pain medicine treatment and primary specialties have significant the development of a of and techniques in the research, diagnosis, and treatment of a the discipline of pain medicine has advances in of the advances in include testing, neurophysiologic testing, central and in pain medicine has by the use of and as as techniques in that of pain and The use of and including and has that pain of the and a in the development and of persistent pain These are also in the and in the of new advances have in and delivery as as is also new that impact in pain and of such as has a of pain and has a impact on treatment the and has knowledge the of pain. have a absence pain. as the the of a with in to pain on the a of to of pain, to to pain with that the of research the of the for the to sense pain in an that the of a in pain, the to experience pain. The the for the of an The that is an and for in These to the development of that selectively this In research, have a delivery to for the of an that is in the clinical to the abilities of this is in patients with pain the of of pain has as for the development of new to pain of research on the of the in pain as as of pain, pain research in is on the The of and research to the of and in pain and in chronic pain are by a new is to the of the of the in pain as as potential new and new has of pain with of the and These advances have to a of such as techniques and In research and treatment are on the of pain. has a to the in for pain and techniques in pain and and the use of that the activity of the pain In to this development in has a significant focus on of pain and of the is a of in neurophysiologic are with the of the and of the to achieve of of the of of the central the by of an delivery also as a is an medical to chronic pain. by the a that the The is the by by is in the harness the to the pain medicine research has to significant and including the development of and progress in the of has to a of for in pain advances in include delivery and the use of for the of and are to an increasing number of persistent pain advances in techniques has of pain, including pain, and common such as and pain. use of and to patients and with that pain and techniques the to in of that are and and the central of pain. research has that such and the most of development in the of pain medicine, the between and pain and are upon advances in the as in this and the such as and have to pain and The of are by patients with the to central and that pain, and the of new and effective as of and that pain and to of and medical treatment. pain and to activity in the of medicine, and medicine has also The of persistent pain, with the treatment of has to the of such for pain. the of is by of in pain of is to cost-effective of integrating techniques the of pain. acute pain is a of an problem of the However, and in of pain be on the this the has a that with the pain this of is of is a of the The of pain a to a is by research that has demonstrated of in patients with chronic pain of a and is development in the discipline of pain new and by the the and is a that describes a process with a and the of to the the and central to pain as a of an an an of to pain, the the such pain is short and persistent and the process is chronic of pain as a of and to is a to pain as a process that to and is the of an to the also a persistent and and to in the the is and is to the and to and is with and of pain is and effective treatment requires a comprehensive, and unified is to that in clinical and and pain, the is an of this of of pain. the for and is a new for the medical discipline that with the comprehensive of pain The in by of the as a of the medical discipline of the medical and that have to as pain are to as The number of pain medicine continues to the in the for the of Pain is the on pain research and treatment. The has and The the pain research and that collaboration in pain The of the the growing progress in the development of pain medicine that has in pain medicine has as a medical specialty in and a number of have the United States in of pain medicine American to in the for a pain care. The has patients and pain medicine by for a to the and effective treatment of pain, for that to pain training of physicians, and for funding of research on pain and In of the for that effective of the treatment of pain, with pain and public and to and to the public in the in the field of pain care has also to and the pain Council on the that to the of pain medicine and are The is a of the in by the with the American Pain and the American and in by the American of The is a of to federal care on behalf of with pain by quality of care and to care and research In to the of the a of Pain and on is the medical the of the in the diagnosis, and treatment in pain medicine are the by and barriers. is evident in the in the number of and publications in pain medicine, as as for in pain care to and and publications the pain. publications the Pain and publications The increasing and of knowledge and that to be as of a comprehensive residency training are in the growth of and in the has in the field of pain medicine for the 50 Pain and publications The increasing and of knowledge and that to be as of a comprehensive residency training are in the growth of and in the has in the field of pain medicine for the 50 In the of the field of pain medicine is highly active, daily advances in research, diagnosis, and in pain care such as and are focus to medicine and in order to to pain treatment. is to barriers in pain care the National Pain Care Policy Act of The pain by 1) a Pain the National of 2) comprehensive pain care and training for care 3) creating a public on pain and 4) creating an of on pain and The legislation is a of by the of in the on by the the of the in 2009. In and the that the of and the of Veterans to pain care of care and to the and research to improve pain treatment for The of Veterans has a for Pain to this pain treatment continues to be a growing problem in the United States. research to pain medicine remains Despite growth in 1) medical 2) and 3) the of the of pain medicine, public funding of pain research in to the for an research In public funding for pain research is in a In the of in the and this has of pain medicine research has with the of pain and continues to in the of the funding an in federal funding for pain the a of in funding a of greater that encountered by the of medical specialties to The in the of a of the that federal funding of pain medicine for of the prevalence of chronic pain in the United States the and the meager in pain research as of with the chronic pain in for of and an estimated in Americans this to the of a on behalf of the this of is to for research as the for to and pain is the most problem that is as the and for and Pain research is the to pain and new is to significant progress pain to of of research The is to significant barriers that the diagnosis, and of pain. the by the of and be by the The calls for the of an of on Pain Care to and the current of pain care. action include pain care research, and clinical care, and These and recommendations be to proposes an of and clinical research, and the of within the of and The funding for to and in pain and treatment to a of Americans is in pain and of has persistent chronic pain The of persistent pain Americans are pain, pain, and pain. the for and that in of American pain and pain that In care for an estimated including for and care. In care for an estimated billion include the following of Americans of pain in the that for of pain in the of a in the of patients have pain. billion of are lost to pain. Pain has to have a significant on and productivity. In a in the of the American Medical that of the in the United States a in of a to a pain pain, and the most common in an estimated billion of this lost in the of are are pain medicine to the of patients suffering with pain and the of pain is The American Board of has of training for existing in pain medicine, to provide pain training specialties However, the have The of to the to pain that are of pain training and that a significant in order to and the by The of resulted in the of existing to the programs, and that a growing of patients with persistent pain, a number that has estimated to million people in the United States on a growing and of pain medicine that be in to provide in pain medicine to specialties the to the to pain and with the growing and focus on in pain medicine, is that comprehensive training in the of pain and treatment is a pain to improve the of current training by the of the to for be a for medical and to pain The for training in a primary specialty by a training be as for to for medical and most of the training of pain in provide for for the of patients with persistent pain. The current for training in the discipline of pain medicine to a fragmented, and to pain medicine training in in pain medicine the of medical training and knowledge that has in the treatment of pain The of knowledge that to the development of pain medicine as a discipline has the current training knowledge and of pain and must of training and for pain medicine In pain medicine is a discipline that is primary care and existing specialty in the and of knowledge and to care to patients with pain. However, current accredited training for in the specialty is to a focus and is of to to the of knowledge and to comprehensive pain pain are the of The process for to have and this process the in the of pain are this training in to pain training is in and are central to pain. in to the clinical and of chronic that are the of chronic pain care, such as and also as is in of most of the and specialties to pain medicine as a training is the current training in most of the that are to comprehensive pain The current training is and as a the discipline of pain medicine and to the of the safety be by the training of and care the between patients pain medicine care and are to provide pain medicine be These the knowledge and to the of pain and the skills, and within the of to the treatment that patients with persistent pain with training provide care. patients and to the of and unnecessary such as Fragmentation of pain care is by the and the and of pain by with diverse training and an is and describes the patient and the pain a specialty the current to a have a focus a of primary on in a be to persistent pain as a process as the is with significant societal and treatment the patient as a human with a fragmented, to to a of and of care is the pain an to patient care, to and to be to patient care also to a is to the and to for the care. is a of the training and is a in the to pain medicine training to a to care in With the in to an with chronic and that are by pain is a for have in pain medicine and training in the of an training in the of medicine and care, and a of care including care and is a for a pain The current training model is in this quality in the delivery of pain medicine also has a societal The of pain treatment in a on people and policies. delivery of pain medicine to for care, causing to take of the current a of within the federal including the for and the and the of have the of pain and the of the current training for within research and such as The and such as by the of Veterans and have also of the of pain care and of advances in pain medicine, and have to and to new of care in the pain medicine is to that pain of are with in the of and pain in and by in and and are in such pain In persistent pain be as a because of with and consequences to and include of in of daily and The discipline of pain medicine has a in development the in as a is that is for pain medicine and and is in and are for of the care and the and to improve the of of Pain medicine in the training of medical and the of pain medicine by the as a primary medical specialty and the development of residency programs, be by and be in quality of care reimbursement for such as in barriers to coordinated care reimbursement for such as therapy, and integrated, pain medicine have the of and The be and of use of resources, and quality of care. Pain medicine is as a with most of the in the to research, and treatment of pain is the of pain medicine as a primary specialty of to medical pain medicine is a The of medicine of patient specialties within the of medicine and as primary specialty a of that and clinical of and of training and to Pain and that the of pain medicine a medical discipline to a primary medical specialty that of to the development of the medicine as a patients in an by a of on to medical of care. of on the medical to such The specialty of medicine and and in most patients are by provide an The diverse are the patient is and of care are The on specialties with greater of knowledge of and the patient to a number of The care by the of and is coordinated by the an discipline is the patient the care is to a specialty a in with The of an integrated, comprehensive, and in the field of medicine as an for a new model of pain care. The describes a medical specialty as of medical knowledge and and training in the are 25 medical specialties in the United States. Pain medicine is the discipline of pain medicine is as a of medicine and and are as primary specialties in the United States. Board in 25 specialties is by of the this between the and medicine be and to as the of Pain in of this the current of training of a fragmented, and to pain medicine training in in pain medicine the of medical training and knowledge that has in the treatment of pain this have is as knowledge and of pain and must of training and for pain medicine in current training that that a medical residency training in an specialty and an as most pain are that most pain medicine have a In most this the focus
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Dubois et al. (2009) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: