Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Chemical bonding is a central topic in general chemistry courses. Lewis (1916) published a fundamental paper where he proposed a model based on localized electron pairs and as a consequence, gave rise to the octet rule. However, the discovery of xenon fluorides and compounds such as SF6 gave rise to the concept of “hypervalence” involving d orbitals in hybridization schemes. Currently, it has been demonstrated that d orbitals have a negligible participation in the bonds of such molecules and, in some cases octet rule is not violated. This article proposes a discussion about the concepts we use in introductory chemistry lectures. Some models are useful and valuable from a pedagogical point of view, nevertheless, others are unnecessary and far from reality causing misconceptions and lack of interest, since it is hard to rationalize inconsistencies found. HClO4 molecule was selected to demonstrate that hypervalence concept, molecular structure selection based on formal charge rules and participation of d orbitals on bonds are not appropriate approximations. Bond orders and atomic charges determined through Natural Bond Orbital calculations indicate bonds between Cl and O atoms are mainly simple with a high ionic character.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Astrid Sánchez (2024) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: