Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
In 2003 the Office for Public Management concluded that: the forces of globalization mean that a nation’s health will depend increasingly on people who can use their positions of leadership to act in appropriate ways to: Lead on global health issues, helping others to understand how globalization and global decision-making affect health at a local level. Provide leadership in health organizations to enhance their positive contribution to health in the context of globalization. Operate in the political and policy arenas where decisions are made about resource allocation, and to advocate the case for treating health as a resource and an investment to support economic and social development, rather than only as a cost. Influence actions of non-health decision-makers, in trade and education policies to have a positive impact on health. This emphasis on leadership was reinforced in England recently with the publication of the Darzi Review (DoH 2008), which has in excess of 50 references to leadership (OT 2009). Produced following a year-long consultation process involving more than 2000 clinicians and 60 000 NHS staff, patients, stakeholders and members of the public, it advocates: ‘Placing a new emphasis on enabling NHS staff to lead and manage the organizations in which they work’ (DoH 2008, p13); and contends that ‘Clinicians are expected to offer leadership, and where they have appropriate skills, take senior leadership and management posts…It requires a new obligation to step up, work with other leaders, both clinical and managerial, and change the system where it would benefit patients’ (DoH 2008, p60); and ‘we need to further develop clinical and managerial leadership (DoH 2008, p61). In order to ensure leadership capacity is developed a National Leadership Council has been established as a sub-committee of the NHS Management Board, with a remit to champion the transformation of leadership across the NHS (Dawson et al. 2009). It is chaired by the NHS Chief Executive David Nicholson and is charged with working to ensure that world-class leadership talent and leadership development exists at every level of the NHS. The recognition of leadership as central to the efficient and effective delivery of health services is founded on a sound empirical base. For example Borrill et al. (2003a,b) combined the data gathered in 2001–2002 from two extensive research programmes involving some 23 720 staff across 134 NHS Trusts, and examined the relationship between leadership and organizational performance. They found that the trusts with effective senior leadership in place had fewer patient complaints, delivered better quality care, and were safer. In addition effective team work among professionals reduced patient mortality (West 2002). In a related piece of work a survey of 203 911 staff in 572 NHS Trusts Borrill et al. (2003a) found that in all types of trusts more positive perceptions of leadership are associated with staff experiencing better quality work-life balance, higher levels of job satisfaction and lower levels of intention to leave. If this is to be achieved studies suggest leaders must be able to: Create strategy Have a vision for change Design new ways of working to respond to these changes Develop others Maintain morale while at the same time maximizing performance Work both within teams and also across boundaries Focus on customers both internal and external and build relationships with them (Williams 2004) Similar lists of skills and competences are central to the NHS Leadership Qualities Framework (NHS Leadership Centre 2004) and the Medical Leadership Competency Framework (NHSIII 2009). The NHS Leadership Qualities Framework is made up of 15 leadership behaviours organized in three clusters. They include such qualities as leading change through people, empowering others, seizing the future, and political astuteness. The framework is designed to be a single model of leadership for all NHS staff. Despite this a separate framework has been produced which describes the leadership competencies that doctors need to become more actively involved in the planning, delivery and transformation of health services (NHSIII 2009). In this framework 20 competences are listed under the five broad headings of: Demonstrating Personal Qualities; Working with Others; Managing Services; Improving Services; and Setting Direction. Whilst this demonstrable commitment to leadership development is welcome, the form it has taken places a significant burden, and indeed reliance on individuals to ensure health care is organized and delivered well. However it is somewhat limited in focussing solely on leaders and their traits. The NHS Qualities Framework, for example has been characterized by Ford (2005) as an attempt to offer a ‘holy grail’ solution to the definitional difficulties associated with leadership, and has become, the assumed identity that NHS Managers and professionals should adopt if they are to become successful leaders in the NHS. The limitations of trait based approaches to leadership have also been identified by Rodgers et al. (2003). In a review conducted on behalf of the Learning and Skills Research Centre, they accessed a wide range of data sources in order to examine research and organizational practices in education, health and public administration across several continents. In addition to questioning the theoretical and empirical base for the competency movement and its tautological implications for the definition of leaders, they concluded there is an associated risk of reverting to a checklist approach to leadership development. Although it may be attractive on the surface, as a way of making sense of the complex task of leadership, it operates from an empirically contested and largely unproven base. Over-reliance on such an approach constrains and undermines meaningful, pertinent, innovative and potentially more effective leadership practice (Rodgers et al. 2003). It also creates a misplaced faith in the leader as the hero and panacea for all organizational ills. In the UK the notion of the ‘leader as saviour’ is currently in vogue, exemplified by the plethora of recent publications promoting ‘excellence’ in leadership policy, practice and development (Collinson 2005). So although leadership can make a difference it is about more than just the leader. Leadership effectiveness is highly contingent on the immediate context. There is no ‘one best way’ to lead, or one ideal set of competencies for a leader. The attributes that render a leader effective in one setting can be disastrous in another (Buchanan 2003). Consequently, the expectation reflected in current policy that if only leaders were adequately prepared then the challenges organized health care presents can be met is misplaced. Not only that, it places unrealistic demands on the individuals appointed to these positions. It is encouraging therefore that in this issue a more nuanced approach is taken to the discussion of leadership. Rather than focusing on the leader alone, the first five papers examine a range of related issues that contribute to the continuing efforts of researchers and managers to uncover the specific elements of this complex phenomenon. The second five papers report work undertaken to study the related areas of staff retention and staff satisfaction, which in many ways are dependent on leadership. Lacey-Haun and Whitehead report an initiative to share an American model for leadership development with an African University. This involved investing in middle manager leaders, as well as adjusting training materials to accommodate cultural differences. In terms of taking a broad perspective on leadership it is clearly recognized in the paper that ‘the elevation of academic leadership from an ad hoc activity to an institutionalized process’ was vital. If effective leadership practice is to take root, then the whole organization must change, not just the leaders. The work of Dellve and Wikström indicates that in some instances we are indeed expecting too much from our leaders. They set out to learn more about the main challenges health care leaders face in managing complex workplace stress and how best to deal with it, by interviewing 39 leader-managers. Again, although the need for a clear leadership role identity was a central feature of the study, organizational support and teamwork were also found to be important elements in tackling stress among the leaders. In interviews with nine senior nurse leaders, Kirk set out to discover the factors her respondents considered to be important to their effectiveness as executive directors. In keeping with much previous ‘trait’ based research, although 12 factors were identified, they were fairly general and could not be used to ‘measure’ effectiveness. Nor could improvement in these areas be related to effective performance as an executive director. This underlines the complexity of leadership, even when considered from one perspective, and as Kirk concludes, warrants further research. There may be conceptual and methodological challenges to overcome in order to increase understanding of the dynamics of the nurse executive director role, yet Henderson and her colleagues are unequivocal in arguing the need for executive leadership to advance useful research activity. In the final paper in the first section an approach to organizational innovation using appreciative inquiry is presented as a means of stimulating innovation. Leaders are often charged with changing services and so Richer et al.’s observations of how this can be undertaken are likely to be of interest to leaders and their team members. The second set of papers summarize some of the contextual factors that can affect the impact a leader can have. They also highlight the myriad issues that leaders in health care need to take account of. Baernholdt and Mark, for example, report the influence elements of the working environment have on the job satisfaction of nurses and how these can be an important factor in their decision to leave employment. Similar issues are examined in Estonia by Hinno et al. who itemize the complex mix of organizational attributes that contribute to a positive perception of the working environment, on the part of nurses. This theme continues in the literature review presented by Utriainen and Kyngăs which concludes that interpersonal relationships and organizational factors, including leadership, are key determinants of hospital nurses’ job satisfaction. A related problem is staff retention and Leese et al. discuss the way Primary Care Trusts in England are implementing policy aimed at retaining nursing staff over the age of 50 years. They suggest that this is an area that will need further monitoring and research as initiatives are at an early stage. Finally Tervo-Heikkinen et al. reinforce the conclusions reached in the preceding papers in section two, producing comparable findings from a large survey conducted in Finland. The combination of workplace pressures and the extent of control individuals could exert over their own practice were key determinants in organizational and patient outcomes. As they conclude ‘From the viewpoint of nursing leadership and management, this analysis stresses the importance of considering multiple issues to develop the quality of the nursing work environment’. Which in a sense brings the argument full circle, returning to the importance of leadership in health care. The enduring concern with leadership is reflected in the 71 papers examining different aspects of this complex concept that have been published in the Journal of Nursing Management over the past 5 years. The papers included in this issue continue this trend, providing an insight into how leadership is being conducted in nursing and identifying just some of the challenges involved. It may be that we expect too much of our leaders as a result of focusing on the individual leader as a ‘quick fix’ for our organizational problems, rather than leadership as a phenomenon characterized by its history and evidence-base accumulated through a number of theoretical perspectives. In so doing we neglect the context and wider range of forces at work in organizations, and risk heaping blame on the leader for being ineffective when he or she fails to meet expectations. It is likely that a similar number of papers will be needed over the next few years if we are to build a more rounded understanding of leadership in nursing and move towards a situation where the expectations we have of our leaders are more realistic. This may help counter the vain hope that hero leaders with all the answers are on their way, and stimulate the development of more collective and contextually sensitive accounts of this dynamic and constantly changing aspect of health care organization.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Alistair Hewison (2009) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: