Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Living donor liver transplantation (LDLT) is becoming increasingly popular due to the shortage of deceased donor organs, offering a viable option for patients in need of a liver transplant. The trend in LDLT in the United States has been one of steady growth over the past decade, with an increasing percentage of liver transplants performed using living donors. Indeed, after a stable annual frequency of LDLTs from 2010 to 2014 (~200 per year), the number of LDLTs doubled to 440 in 2019.1 This increase highlights the relevance of continuously investigating the components affecting LDLT outcomes and into the best surgical approach that can, at the same time, foster the best outcomes for the recipient and ensure the safest surgical experience for the donor. In this issue of Liver Transplantation, Ziogas et al2 conducted a meta-analysis to evaluate the effectiveness of minimally invasive techniques for living donor hepatectomy. In fact, as explained in the study aim, the gradual and widespread adoption of minimally invasive (MI) liver surgery around the world has led to evidence indicating that MI hepatectomy can achieve outcomes that are equal or even superior to those obtained with open hepatectomy. In this meta-analysis, the available evidence suggested an advantage in terms of estimated blood loss and length of hospital stay for pure laparoscopic living donor hepatectomy (PLLDH) and robotic living donor hepatectomy (RLDH). Unfortunately, the scarcity and heterogeneity of studies comparing PLLDH versus RLDH did not allow the authors to meta-analyze donor outcomes for that comparison. DONOR’S EXPERIENCE Donor’s experience of the surgical procedure cannot be overlooked. Although the primary focus of the hepatectomy is to ensure the patient’s health and well-being, the cosmetic aspect is one of the main concerns raised by most living donors.3 MI hepatectomy can offer a cosmetic advantage over open hepatectomy as it uses smaller incisions, which can result in less scarring and a more esthetically pleasing appearance. Young donors may still be in the prime of their life, and the impact of visible scars can have a lasting effect on their physical and mental health, affecting self-confidence and self-esteem. By taking steps to minimize scarring and providing support to donors, surgeons can help to ensure a positive outcome both physically and emotionally. Furthermore, compared with open hepatectomy, which involves a large incision and longer hospital stays, an MI surgical approach accelerates recovery times, allowing a quicker return to normal activities. This hallmark is extremely important to consider. Indeed, donors usually give importance to resuming their regular routine and getting back to work as soon as possible. Many of them hold demanding positions or have obligations that necessitate being in good physical condition and keeping up with their activities. If they have to refrain from these tasks for an extended period, it can impact their willingness to donate. MINIMALLY INVASIVE TECHNIQUES PLLDH is a highly specialized and technically demanding procedure that requires considerable experience and skill. Because of its complexity, only a few highly trained surgeons are proficient and confident in performing it. On the other hand, RLDH has the potential to make liver hepatectomy more accessible to a wider range of surgeons. Indeed, when working in a confined space or in hard-to-reach areas during PLLDH, suturing can be challenging even for experienced surgeons. The enhanced visualization, precision, and flexibility provided by the robotic system can help to overcome these difficulties and allow access to difficult-to-reach areas more easily. For this reason, as more surgeons gain experience, we can expect to see a similar trend in the use of robotic procedures for LDLT, as has been seen with laparoscopic donor nephrectomy (LDN) and kidney transplantation. Indeed, before the availability of LDN, only 39.0% of referrals were able to find a potential donor for living kidney donation, and of those, only 16.5% received a living donor transplant within 3 years. However, after the introduction of LDN, 50% of patients were able to find at least 1 potential donor, and within 3 years, 24.7% received a living donor transplant.4 ROBOTIC TRAINING AND OUTCOMES To ensure that robotic hepatectomy follows the same positive trend as LDN, it is imperative that more focus is given to comprehensive training programs. These can be organized by transplant centers or professional organizations and can include a combination of didactic sessions, simulation training, and live surgical observation. The use of simulation training allows surgeons to practice and refine their skills in a controlled environment, while live surgical observation provides an opportunity for surgeons to observe the procedure in real time. The inclusion of experienced proctors in the training program can be particularly helpful, as they can provide personalized guidance and feedback in areas where the surgeon needs improvement, speeding up the learning process. In the next years, a holistic approach to analyzing outcomes after the widespread use of RLDH will be critical. Factors such as patient selection, surgical planning, and team communication can all have a significant impact on surgical outcomes, regardless of the specific surgical techniques used. Therefore, understanding the reasons behind a negative outcome can help us identify opportunities for improvement and develop strategies to optimize outcomes. This might include additional training or education for surgeons, changes to surgical protocols, or improvements in patient selection criteria. By prioritizing the development of high-quality training programs and selecting experienced surgeons, we can ensure that robotic hepatectomy becomes a safe and effective option for living liver donation, increasing the number of donations.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Spaggiari et al. (2023) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: