Medullary fixation is a sound therapy for specific femoral shaft fractures in adults, offering advantages like early ambulation, but requires strict adherence to indications and preoperative planning to avoid complications.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
May support medullary fixation in select femoral shaft fractures with strict indications; leaves open need for prospective validation.
The scope of medullary fixation of the femur is now well defined. Under ideal circumstances, this method can now be accepted as sound therapy, offering many advantages over older and more orthodox forms of treatment. The nail provides internal fixation sufficiently strong and rigid to eliminate the need for casts, splints, or braces. Nursing care is simplified. Early ambulation and weight bearing and mobilization of joints minimize the period of hospitalization and convalescence and decrease the final degree of disability to a minimum. Impaction or coaptation of the fracture surfaces is recognized as a desirable physiological stimulus to union. The medullary nail is a near-perfect mechanical appliance to take advantage of this favorable factor. Over-zealous attempts, however, to capitalize on early mobilization and restoration of function in improperly selected cases can lead only to trouble. Surgeons with the most experience recognize the limitations of medullary nailing, and supplement the nail during part or all of the healing period with external support if the fracture is not rigidly fixed. Thus, the optimum advantages of the medullary nail do not accrue in all femoral shaft fractures nor in other long bones. Before selecting this technic as the procedure of choice, a surgeon should realize that medullary fixation, more than any other, offers a great array of complications. Optimum results can be achieved only by the strictest adherence to the following requisites: 1. This technic is applicable only to a specific group of fractures. 2. The patient should be able to withstand a major surgical procedure. 3. Preoperative planning must be thorough, particularly the calculation of the length and diameter of the nail. 4. This is not a technic to approach casually; proper instruments, adequate assistants, and optimum hospital conditions are necessary for skillful insertion of the nail. 5. The limitations of metallic fixation apply to medullary nails; namely, the appliance will inevitably bend or break if subjected to undue strain during convalescence; a metal rod is not a substitute for union. Indications Medullary fixation is much too radical for fractures of children or adolescents. They get along quite well with simpler methods. Other than this, age is not a factor. Because of the anatomy of the canal, however, and the osteoporosis of the bone, the results of medullary fixation in elderly patients are likely to be less dependable and stable than in younger individuals. Earlier experience should be limited to transverse or short oblique fractures in the middle two quarters of the shaft, viz., 2 inches below the lesser trochanter and at least 7 inches above the adductor tubercle. As one gains in experience, the indication can be expanded to embrace comminuted or even segmented fractures, provided the degree of comminution does not preclude adequate supplemental fixation.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Hugh M. Smith (1953) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: