Factitious Elevation of Thyrotropin in a New Ultrasensitive Assay: Implications for the Use of Monoclonal Antibodies in “Sandwich” Immunoassay

Three patients who had falsely elevated serum TSH concentrations (initial values, 30.5, 74, and greater than 50 mU/L) in a mouse monoclonal immunoradiometric assay are reported. Two patients were treated for hypothyroidism inappropriately, and one underwent unnecessary diagnostic testing. Immunoaffinity chromatography of serum from one patient indicated that the serum TSH level was truly low. Addition of mouse serum or immunoglobulin G (IgG) or absorption of patient serum with solid phase-bound mouse IgG-1 reduced the TSH content in the serum of the three patients to undetectable levels. Blocking studies revealed that all patients had antibodies directed at mouse IgG-1, the subclass of mouse antibody present in the assay kit. The serum of one patient who had autoimmune disease with elevated serum Igs had much broader species cross-reactivity than that of another patient who had known exposure to rats and mice. We hypothesize that such antimouse antibodies can arise either from endogenous autoimmunity or exogenous animal exposure. Serum TSH elevations also were found when the serum samples were tested in other mouse monoclonal immunoassays, underscoring the fact that antibody interference can potentially affect many assays used in endocrinology and other areas of medicine to make major diagnostic and therapeutic decisions. Clinicians must be aware of such interactions; relatively simple laboratory maneuvers can differentiate true from false results in assays of this type.