This is the authors' abstract. We don't add key points for this paper.
The major contribution of ionizing radiation to the treatment of cancer of the breast consists of the remarkable results that irradiation can accomplish in the management of advanced cases. That statement will be substantiated by this communication which reports a series comprised of 109 patients, in 87 per cent of whom the disease was in the advanced and late stages. Treatment was primarily irradiation, and the follow-up period was more than five years. The program was based on the premise that all advanced carcinomas were inoperable and should be treated with radical irradiation. The objective was the control, with x radiation alone, of the primary malignant tumor involving the breast and every possible regional extension to its lymphatic drainage. The irradiation was not meant to be a “preoperative” measure, although eventually 23 per cent of the patients were subjected to postirradiation mastectomy. The elaboration of our plan for the treatment of advanced cancer of the breast arose some twenty years ago from striving to make an objective evaluation of the therapeutic procedures available (5). The results of radical mastectomy were generally poor in advanced cases (Stage III), showing recurrence rates of approximately 40 per cent and five-year survivals of 0–15 per cent. When edema of the skin was present in such cases, Haagensen (11) had observed that the lymphatics were blocked by carcinoma emboli, the local recurrence rate following radical mastectomy was extremely high (66 per cent in 41 patients), and the five-year clinical cure rate was nil. Postoperative irradiation in advanced cases (Stage III) seemed to have little or no effect on the five-year survival rates which remained practically the same (0 to 15 per cent) as with surgery alone. Preoperative irradiation was beginning to be regarded by some as a method of treatment which might be superior to postoperative administration. Adair's report (1) of microscopic evidence of eradication of cancer in the breast and nodes following preoperative irradiation was impressive. Lenz's experience (13) with preoperative irradiation was also noteworthy. The outstanding need for improvement in the treatment of breast cancer was in the advanced cases in which the results were universally unsatisfactory, regardless of the method of treatment, whether by surgery alone or associated with irradiation. Portmann (20) had advocated in 1937 treatment of advanced cancers of the breast (Stage III) with x radiation alone. Very few reports were available on the results of radiation therapy when used alone against breast cancer, yet papers published by Evans and Leucutia (10), Pendergrass and Hodes (19), Soiland (24), and also Lenz (13) described definite clinical regression following irradiation only. In spite of that, radiation therapy was accepted as a valid palliative measure only, and its potential curative value was far from being regarded as established.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
J Bouchard (1965) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: