Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Radical mastectomy is generally accepted as the most effective means of eradicating early carcinoma of the breast. When cases are selected according to Haagensen's clinical and biopsy criteria of operability (1, 2), and when the operation is performed according to the technic of Halsted, a fairly satisfactory percentage of patients can be cured with reasonably low operative morbidity and mortality. For a significant number of breast carcinomas, however, radical mastectomy can do little. In some instances the disease has progressed too far, either locally or by distant metastasis. In others, serious systemic conditions prohibit curative surgery. Some patients have so-called inflammatory carcinoma (3), which reacts quite unfavorably to operation (4, 5). All of these cases must be managed by other means—radiotherapeutic, chemotherapeutic, hormonal, or some combination of these. It is with the experience of The Massachusetts General Hospital with radiation therapy of inoperable carcinoma of the breast that this report deals. Patient Material From 1944 through 1959, 97 patients (approximately 4 per cent of all of those seen with breast carcinoma) received radiation therapy at the Massachusetts General Hospital as the primary means of treatment. All were white females. These 97 cases are the basis of this report. Patients treated primarily by mastectomy, or by hormones or chemotherapy alone, and those with early carcinoma inoperable because of other severe disease or advanced age were excluded from this study. History and Diagnosis The average age when the diagnosis was made was 59.8 years. The range was from thirty to eighty-five years. Twenty-four (25 per cent) of the patients were seventy or over; 20 (20.5 per cent) were forty-nine or under. The earliest symptoms noticed by these women varied. Slightly more than half (55 per cent) first noticed a mass or lump in the breast. An additional 15 per cent mentioned heaviness, stiffness, or growth of the breast as the first evidence of the disease. In the remainder, redness of the breast (7 patients), an axillary mass (6 patients), discomfort in the breast (4 patients), and retraction of nipple or breast (4 patients) were initial complaints. There were 3 patients whose disease was manifested as swelling of the arm. In a few instances, the records failed to indicate the earliest symptom. The average length of history prior to diagnosis was 12.9 months. The range was from three weeks to five years. Twenty-seven patients (28 per cent) gave histories of less than three months; 23 patients (24 per cent) of two years or more. Of the 97 patients, 21 had tumor in the upper outer quadrant, 6 in the lower outer quadrant, 5 in the lower inner quadrant, and 4 in the upper inner quadrant. In 12 cases the tumor was found to be centrally located.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Griscom et al. (1962) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: