Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The network theory of mental disorder represents a possible paradigm shift inpsychopathological research, and may permanently change the way we studymental health and illness. This theory has one fundamental assumption:psychopathology is driven by direct causal relationships between individualsymptoms. Despite this, surprisingly little has been written about the formalrole of causality in driving network dynamics. In this article, I formalizethe principle of direct causal connections from Borsboom (2017, principle 3)using the framework of structural causal models advanced by Judea Pearl.I then refine the principle of hysteresis from Borsboom (2017, principle 5)by identifying causal feedback as the second necessary condition for hysteresisto occur (in addition to connectivity strength). Finally, I discuss howthese refinements lead to new insights about concepts like ‘treatment’ and‘comorbidity’. Understanding the causal structure of symptom networks isintegral to understanding how mental disorders develop, and how they maybe treated.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Peder Mortvedt Isager (2023) studied this question.