Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Luther and Calvin on the Role of Faith in the Sacraments:A Catholic Analysis Michael Root What is the causal role of faith in the sacraments as understood by the Protestant Reformers? The Catholic might think that this question is simpler than a parallel question addressed to Catholic understandings of sacraments. After all, Protestants generally affirm only two sacraments, baptism and the Eucharist,2 or even (the Catholic might say) only one-and-a-half, since the sacrificial aspect of the Eucharist is uniformly denied by Protestants (or, on occasion, affirmed in a way that pushes it to the margins). The field to be explored is thus significantly smaller. But the initial glance is deceiving for two reasons. First, the rejection of Scholasticism by the Reformers meant that the conceptual resources available for discussing the causal role of faith (or anything else) in the sacraments are less precise than those available within Catholic discussions.3 Figuring out just what is the [End Page 1065] causal role of faith in the sacraments for the Reformers is a complex interpretive task. Second, there is no shared Protestant understanding of the role of faith in the sacraments. In fact, the role of faith in the Eucharist became a central topic of Lutheran–Reformed dispute, with the Lutherans accusing the Reformed of making faith a cause of Christ's presence, in the sense of efficient cause, and the Reformed accusing the Lutherans of bypassing faith, in ascribing an inappropriate power to the material elements of baptismal water and Eucharistic bread and wine. While disputes over baptism were less prominent, Lutherans and Reformed did take significantly different positions on baptism and faith, leading to differences in practice, notably the Lutheran tendency to baptize infants in danger of death and a Reformed reluctance to do so. Thus, any attempt to understand the causal role of faith in relation to the sacraments must at least take up the different strands of Protestant theology separately. In order to make my task manageable, I will deal here with only the two most important theologians of the Protestant Reformation, Martin Luther and John Calvin, who represent two of the three most important strands of classical Protestant theology. I will thus not address those theologians, few in the sixteenth century but of increasing importance in later Protestant history, who may be described as simply nonsacramental—who denied that sacraments are divine actions that in some way communicate grace, instead understanding them as human actions attesting to or calling to mind a reality independent of the sacramental rite itself. For such theologians, Zwingli being the most important from the sixteenth century, the question of sacramental causality takes a quite different form. This article will be something of a cross-border exploration. The question of sacramental causality as it has been discussed in Catholic theology was not discussed in such terms by Protestants, although the underlying issues that gave rise to the Catholic discussion were present for Protestant theologians as well, at least for those who can be called sacramental. I will thus be asking a Catholic question of Protestant theology: what sort of causal or cause-like role does faith play in the sacraments? My hope is that this cross-border excursion will cast a different light both on Protestant discussions and, by reflection, on how Catholics understand faith and the sacraments. Cross-border trips can be messy and hobbled by misunderstanding. Matters are made more complicated by the less than perfectly clear accounts of faith and the sacraments offered by both Luther and Calvin. I will thus need to make some summary claims about each [End Page 1066] that would not be universally accepted by all interpreters, and I will not have space here to defend them. I will offer extensive quotations from both, but I know that quotations that seem to point in a different direction can also be found. Faith A preliminary comment needs to be made about one of the central terms being employed, faith, and the role of faith in salvation and the Christian life. The word "faith" almost always carries a different range of reference and a different set of connotations for Protestant theologians than...
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Michael Root (2017) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: