The experimental phonon-dispersion curves of aluminum at 80^∘{}K and at 300^∘{}K have been analyzed in terms of axially symmetric Born-von K\'arm\'an force-constant models, including 8 nearest neighbors. The resulting models have been used to compute a frequency distribution function g(ω) at each temperature from which various thermodynamic properties have been derived. The specific-heat curve predicted by the g(ω) appropriate to 80^∘{}K fits excellently the experimental results in the temperature range 20 to 80^∘{}K. At higher temperatures the experimental results deviate from this calculated curve and approach the curve appropriate to g(ω) at 300^∘{}K. Similar behavior is found for the experimental Debye-Waller coefficient in the range above 100^∘{}K. It is concluded that inelastic-neutron-scattering data and thermodynamic data are compatible in the range of sufficiently low temperatures where deviations from the quasiharmonic approximation are small, provided a good force-constant model as well as a statistically adequate g(ω) are available. There is evidence that the quasiharmonic approximation in aluminum is invalid at room temperature at least for the extreme low-frequency part of g(ω).
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Gilat et al. (1966) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 5 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: